The 13 Best Store Bought Pizza Sauces

Girl-is-placing-tomato-sauce-on-fresh-pizza

Pizza is now a favorite the world over, but what can you do if you fancy making homemade pizza without needing to whip up absolutely everything from scratch?

Well, one handy hack is to use store bought pizza sauce.

You may not achieve the same effect as making tomato sauce from scratch, but you won’t need to take all day making it either.

So, you don’t need much by the way of equipment to make pizza dough at home. We also have a couple of handy guides to making pizza right here:

If you’re looking to shortcut the process, you should consider the following pointers when comparing store bought pizza sauces:

  • Jars or cans: You’ll find pizza sauce in both jars and cans. Some cans contain BPA, a potential harmful toxin. Always look for BPA-free cans. The other possible flashpoint with buying packs of cans is that they sometimes arrived damaged in transit. Glass jars are a superior alternative for pizza sauce
  • Quality of tomatoes: While not all pizza sauces contain tomatoes, all those we review today do as we are striving for an authentic Italian experience. Look for whole vine-ripened tomatoes, ideally certified organic and non-GMO
  • Type of oil: Olive oil is both lighter and healthier than sunflower oil, so look for olive oil in pizza sauce, preferably extra-virgin olive oil. While this might seem like a minor concern, high-quality olive oil will improve the taste and texture of your sauce
  • Texture: You should look for a pizza sauce with a pretty thick consistency. If the sauce is too thin and watery, it could easily make your pizza dough soggy. This stops the pizza from cooking properly. Sauces without veggies are best. What you’re looking for is a thick yet smooth consistency for first-class and authentic Italian pizza
  • Spiciness: Some pizza sauce can be quite spicy, so make sure you are OK with fiery food if you’re considering a feistier sauce
  • Fat, carb, and calorie content: If you are following a keto, paleo, or other low-carb diet, many of the pizza sauces we review today are very low in carbs. The majority of the sauces we review are also low in calories, sugar, and fats. You should have no trouble finding some sauce that gels with your dietary requirements
  • Organic: Not everyone is motivated to buy organic produce, and we’re not here to convince you otherwise. For many, though, eco-conscious products are not only worth considering, but worth paying a premium for. We review a handful of organic sauces today, all placing a premium on organic and non-GMO ingredient to bring you the best possible experience with the least environmental impact. If you’re not a huge fan of organic products or the stiff price tags, we review plenty of tasty tomato-based sauces to bring out the best in your homemade pizza. All that counts is finding what’s right for your needs and your budget

If you keep these simple pointers in mind, you should have no problem finding the best store bought pizza sauce for you and your family.

Enjoy!

Madibarestaurant.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

I. The 13 Best Store Bought Pizza Sauces

1. Our #1 Pick: Don Pepino Pizza Sauce

Don-Pepino-Pizza-Sauce

Features

  • Can size: 14.5oz
  • Weight: 12.48 pounds
  • Dimensions: 12.48 x 9.17 x 4.57 inches

First up and our overall favorite in today’s search for the best store bought pizza sauce comes from Don Pepino, so how does this stuff shape up?

The main selling point here is the family-run firm producing the same classic tomato sauce for pizzas since 1950.

Aside from this unbeatable brand heritage, the other prime benefit involves the fresh and vine-ripened tomatoes this sauce is made from.

The sauce is dairy-free and also contains no cholesterol, making it a reasonably healthy option if you’re looking to enjoy homemade pizza with a healthier kick.

When it comes to the texture, this stuff is quite thick and dense, so you’ll avoid waterlogged crusts and get the best topping for perfect pie.

If you want a pizza sauce with a strong, robust flavor, this is not for you. The tomato sauce is subtle rather than overpowering and gives you a great neutral base to load with your favorite toppings – that’s where you can really get the pizza kicking.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Fresh and vine-ripened tomatoes
  • Rich, dense texture
  • No cholesterol
  • Reasonably bland

2. Chef Boyardee Pizza Sauce

Chef-Boyardee-Pizza-Sauce-with-Cheese

Features

  • Can size: 15oz
  • Weight: 12.79 pounds
  • Dimensions: 12.24 x 9.02 x 4.65 inches

Next in line comes another great store bought sauce to liven up your homemade pizza, this time from the Chef Boyardee stable.

More and more people these days have various dietary restrictions, and if you want a low-calorie tomato sauce that’s also very low in carbs, you’re in luck here.

This keto-friendly tomato sauce has only 3g of net carbs from 4g of total carbs in each serving, making it ideal for keto, paleo, and other low-carb eating plans.

There are also only 35 calories in each serving of this sauce, giving you homemade pizza that’s easy on the waistline – as long as you restrain yourself when it comes to the toppings.

Packed with flavor – the sauce contains tomatoes and cheese – this is one of the best options at your disposal if you’re looking to whip up some pizza at home instead of ordering in or heading to the pizzeria.

Aside from some isolated complaints about quality control, the vast bulk of user reviews of this family favorite are overwhelmingly positive. As with all tomato sauces for pizza, though, taste is entirely subjective, so why not just give some of this stuff a try?

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Very low carb content
  • Richly flavored with tomato and cheese
  • Low in calories
  • Quality control issues flagged

3. Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauces

Rao's-Homemade-Pizza-Sauce

Features

  • Can size: 13oz
  • Weight: 0.81 pounds
  • Dimensions: 4.7 x 2.9 x 2.8 inches

If you’re comparing the best store bough pizza sauces, you can’t avoid Rao’s Homemade. This premium brand is based in New York City, and produces authentic Italian sauces to liven up your homemade attempts at pizza or pasta.

This pizza sauce is just one entry in a deep bench of lip-smacking additions to your kitchen.

Made from all-Italian tomatoes – both peeled whole tomatoes and cherry tomatoes – along with a blend of onions, garlic, oregano, and basil, you’ll get a simple but highly effective sauce just like you would find in Italy.

What you don’t get in a pizza sauce is almost as important as what is included. Here, you get no sugar added, making the sauce ideal for diabetics.

This is also a low-carb sauce that works well if you’re following the keto or paleo diet.

All-natural, the tomato sauce is also low in calories, completing a tasty and nutritious package from a brand you can rely on.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • 100% Italian tomatoes
  • No added sugar
  • All-natural and keto-friendly
  • Not the strongest flavor

4. Muir Glen Pizza Sauce

Muir-Glen,-Organic-Diced-No-Salt-Added-Tomatoes

Features

  • Can size: 15oz
  • Weight: 12.83 pounds
  • Dimensions: 3 x 3 x 4.38 inches

Muir Glen is another brand with a heavy presence in this vertical, and a line of impressive organic sauces.

As you would expect from an all-organic product, this pizza sauce is certainly not the cheapest option you’ll find. If you’re looking for budget sauces, we review several above and below. If you’re looking for quality despite the cost, read on.

This sauce is made from whole Californian tomatoes cooked down into a thick paste ideal for keeping the crusts on your homemade pizzas dry. These are not just any tomatoes, though. Grown on organic farms, they are certified organic by the USDA, and they are also non-GMO, growing under the abundant natural sunshine of California.

The extra-virgin olive oil also separates this pizza sauce from much of the lower quality opposition.

Beyond this, the tomatoes are cooked with a simple mix of sea salt, black pepper, oregano, basil, and onions, as well as the ubiquitous garlic.

While the cost per can might not be cheap, you get great overall value with this pack of a dozen pizza sauces. Why not treat yourself for the looming holiday season?

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Organic extra-virgin olive oil
  • Tomatoes grown on organic farms
  • Bumper value 12-pack
  • Quite costly

5. Ragú Pizza Sauce

Ragú-Homemade-Style-Pizza-Sauce,-14-oz

Features

  • Can size: 14oz
  • Weight: 14oz
  • Dimensions: 2.8 x 2.9 x 5 inches

We have another highly reputable brand up next in the shape of Ragú. Founded by Italian-American immigrants in the early 1900s, the company continues to produce authentic Italian sauces and foods.

This homemade pizza sauce tends to polarize opinion. Some find this stable of sauces to be tainted with a slightly artificial flavor, while millions of others the world over praise its Sicilian authenticity.

A simple tomato sauce, this works well as the base for any toppings that take your fancy. If you are opting for a classic margherita, though, you may want to consider some of the sauces we review with a richer, deeper flavor.

You also get a proprietary blend of spices thrown in, so you can liven up homemade pizza without the tomato sauce dominating.

If you’re looking for one of the best store bought pizza sauces out there from a brand that’s been in business for over a century, you can’t go wrong with Ragú.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Simple tomato sauce
  • Made with real tomatoes
  • Blend of spices
  • Slightly artificial taste

6. Muir Glen Organic Tomatoes

Muir-Glen,-Organic-Tomatoes

Features

  • Can size: 15oz
  • Weight: 11.24 pounds
  • Dimensions: 12 x 6 x 5.6 inches

We have another entry from the Muir Glen stable up next with these organic tomatoes ideal for smearing all over your homemade pizza dough.

Now, if you’re looking for cheap store bought pizza sauce, this is not your best bet. If, however, quality is your prime concern, you won’t be disappointed with Muir Glen.

The tomatoes are grown on organic farms in California, benefiting from an abundance of year-round natural sunshine. Certified organic and also non-GMO, you get an eco-conscious option that’s also lip-smackingly good.

These premium whole tomatoes are cooked down after being peeled and seasoned delicately with sea salt.

There is no cholesterol in this stuff, and you’ll find no fats or trans-fats either, so there is absolutely no need to go without pizza, even if you’re on a diet.

If you want a sauce for your pizza that packs a real kick, this is not your strongest option. For lovers of authentic Italian tomato sauce, just lightly flavored but full of the powerful goodness of prime tomatoes, you’ll be blown away.

While these are not the cheapest tomatoes out there, by investing in this 12-pack, you’ll bring the cost-per-can down to a much more manageable level.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Organic tomatoes seasoned with sea salt
  • Field to can in just 8 hours
  • Subtle but powerful flavor
  • Not the cheapest store bought pizza sauce

7. Ragú Pizza Sauce

Pizza-Sauce-Ragu-Homemade-Style-14-Oz

Features

  • Can size: 14oz
  • Weight: 4.48 pounds
  • Dimensions: 4 x 3 x 2.6 inches

Ragú has a wide range of great sauces for all occasions, including this delightful homemade pizza sauce.

As always with this iconic brand, there is not much written about the ingredients of this stuff. The sauce is made from a rich tomato purée that’s seasoned with salt and proprietary spices. The result is a traditional tomato sauce that blends into your pizza rather than standing out.

Whenever you try a new tomato sauce, there’s always a chance you won’t like the taste, even if you’ve taken the time to do plenty of research. This small pack of 3 jars means it’s not the end of the world if you pick up some Ragú and determine you don’t like the way it goes with your pizza toppings.

This sauce is slightly thin and watery, so be careful it doesn’t get the crust of your pizza too moist.

As an added benefit, this pizza sauce is low in calories, and it’s also super-low in fat and carbs, making it a great choice for most diets.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Great brand heritage
  • Simple tomato sauce
  • Spices blended for a slight kick
  • Quite thin and watery

8. Williams Sonoma San Marzano Pizza Sauce

San-Marzano-Pizza-Sauce

Features

  • Can size: 18oz
  • Weight: 1.125 pounds
  • Dimensions: 4.5 x 2.5 x 2.5 inches

As we near the end of our showcase of the best store bought pizza sauce, we have an entry from the exclusive Williams Sonoma stable in the shape of this San Marzano pizza sauce. What do you get for your money, then?

Well, the first thing you should do is be prepared to pay a little more for this sauce than some of the competition. Ask yourself this, though. How did it go the last time you looked for cheap store bought pizza sauce?

If you’re prepared to dig deeper for a premium sauce, you’ll benefit from the powerful sweetness of the San Marzano tomatoes imported from Italy loaded into this sauce. The tomatoes are complemented by a simple blend of garlic and basil, delivering an authentic Italian taste sensation.

When you’re comparing store bought pizza sauces to spice up your homemade pie, texture should be uppermost on your mind. This sauce is thick and dense, preventing your pizza dough from getting soggy.

The other key ingredient in this sauce is the extra-virgin olive oil the other ingredients are simmered in to give you this, arguably the best store bought pizza sauce out there. Let us know what you think if you treat yourself to a jar or two of this stuff.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Rich and flavor-filled
  • Chunky texture
  • Impeccable brand image
  • Reasonably expensive

9. Contadina Pizza Sauce

Contadina-Pizza-Squeeze-Pizza-Sauce

Features

  • Can size: 15oz
  • Weight: 3.09 pounds
  • Dimensions: 8.31 x 5.79 x 3.39 inches

If you prefer pizza sauces in squeezy bottles – and it does make it very easy to slather all over your pie dough – you’re in luck with Contadina.

You get a 3-pack of plastic bottles, each containing 15oz of rich tomato sauce ideal for smearing all over your homemade pizza.

The sauce is made using Roma tomatoes, prized for their sweetness and depth of flavor.

Each serving of this sauce contains only 30 calories, giving you plenty of leeway with your toppings. There is no cholesterol, also this sauce is quite salty, with 14% of your RDA of sodium. There is no fat, no trans-fat, and there are also very few carbs, making the sauce a neat fit with paleo and keto diets.

The sauce works well on more than just homemade pizza, too. Spread it on some bagels or muffins, or use this stuff to liven up some sandwiches.

The 3-pack means you can give this sauce a try without needing to worry too much if you aren’t the biggest fan.

For one of the best squeezy pizza sauces out there from an industry specialist, you can’t go wrong with Contadina.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • User-friendly squeezy bottle
  • Uses Roma-style tomatoes
  • Quite low in carbs
  • Only available in 3-packs

10. Prego Traditional Pizza Sauce

Prego-Traditional-Pizza-Sauce,-Traditional

Features

  • Can size: 14oz
  • Weight: 14oz
  • Dimensions: 5.3 x 2.8 x 2.8 inches

Prego is a name that needs no introduction. If you’re looking to make homemade pizza with a tried-and-true sauce in place, this might be just what you’ve been waiting for.

The base of this sauce are vine-ripened tomatoes packed with sweetness and a rich depth of flavor that works wonderfully with pizza or pasta.

The only real drawback with this sauce is the fact the consistency is slightly too watery, and you could find it imparts a little too much moisture to the crust of your pie.

This sauce makes a great starter choice if you have no idea what you’re looking for in a pizza sauce. You can pick up single 14oz jars, so even if you find the taste is not for you, you won’t have a large crate going to waste.

The recipe is completely gluten-free, making this a flexible choice for those with dietary restrictions.

Prego is another brand that keeps its recipe low-key. You get blended spices to pep up those sweet tomatoes, and you get a rich tomato purée, too.

On the downside, the sauce is made using canola oil in place of the extra-virgin olive oil you find in the very best pizza sauces.

This is another tomato sauce that’s low in both calories and carbs, so you have more leeway when it comes to indulging in fatty toppings.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Made from super-sweet tomatoes
  • Gluten-free recipe
  • Deep and rich flavor
  • Slightly watery consistency

11. Mutti Pizza Sauce

Mutti-14-oz.-6-Pack-of-Pizza-Sauce

Features

  • Can size: 14oz
  • Weight: 6.15 pounds
  • Dimensions: 9.69 x 6.14 x 4.45 inches

As we push on with our store bought pizza sauce reviews, we have some simple but highly effective tomato sauce from Mutti, so what do you get for your money?

This stuff is certified organic, and it’s also completely non-GMO. For anyone looking for sustainable tomato sauce that contains everything you need and nothing you don’t, this sauce is well worth popping on your shortlist.

Beyond this, you also get a tomato sauce that meshes with both gluten-free and vegan diets.

The sauce comes in 14oz cans, and you’ll get 6 cans in each pack, so you should make sure you’re confident that you’ll like this stuff before committing to a multipack.

In terms of texture, you get a thick sauce that’s easy to apply, and which won’t end up saturating the crusts of your pizza. The consistency is such that you could also use this in tapenades, or served as a standalone dipping sauce.

Most user reviews for this sauce sing its praises, and the only real gripes we found concern quality control issues, dented cans in particular.

On the plus side, these cans are BPA-free, and they are also recyclable.

Overall, you’re getting one of the best store bought pizza sauces out there, even if it’s not the cheapest.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Certified organic
  • Non-GMO
  • Gluten-free and vegan-friendly
  • Quality control issues flagged

12. Botticelli Italian Pizza Sauce

Botticelli-Premium-Italian-Pizza-Sauce-for-Authentic-Italian-Taste

Features

  • Can size: 12.3oz
  • Weight: 1.54 pounds
  • Dimensions: 6.5 x 5.25 x 3.25 inches

As we near the end of our quest for the best store bought pizza sauce, we have a great gourmet option from Botticelli.

Choose from a variety of pack sizes to suit and take advantage of a low-calorie sauce that’s also very low in carbs, making it a perfect accompaniment for anyone on a keto or paleo diet.

The whole tomatoes are cooked down in extra-virgin olive oil, and then cooked with carrots, onion, garlic, sea salt, and oregano for an all-Italian taste sensation.

To avoid the issue of dented cans, Botticelli seals this sauce into glass jars, allowing you to cook with confidence.

Low in sugar, carbs, and calories, treat yourself to homemade pizza without worrying about your waistline.

All that remains is to choose how many jars of this stuff you want and then to put it into action on some fresh pizza dough.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Multiple pack sizes available
  • Low-carb and keto-friendly
  • Sealed in premium glass jars
  • Pretty pricey

13. Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce

Rao's-Homemade-All-Natural-Pizza-Sauce

Features

  • Can size: 13oz
  • Weight: 7.5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 10 x 7 x 6 inches

To round out our hunt for the best store bought pizza sauce, we have yet another entry from Rao’s Homemade, a brand with a stranglehold on this vertical.

This premium tomato sauce is made using whole tomatoes cooked down with a subtle blend of spices and seasoning.

Although the flavor of this tomato sauce is not overpowering, it acts as a robust base for your pizza toppings, lending an authentic Italian touch to pizza night at home.

The texture of this stuff is thick and rewarding, and it won’t end up soaking the crusts of your pie either.

While you’ll need to dig reasonably deep for this store bought pizza sauce, you’ll be saving so much money by making pizza at home, you can afford to indulge yourself.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Impeccable brand image
  • 6-pack for small families
  • Low-fat and low-carb sauce
  • Not the cheapest pizza sauce

II. FAQs

1) What is the sauce used for pizzas?

Although you can use many types of sauce on pizza, most include tomato as the base ingredient. There are also peppery sauces, barbecue sauces, and creamy alfredo sauces up for grabs, so imagination is your only limitation. For the purposes of today, we have kept things traditional and opted for nothing but tomato sauces.

2) What is the difference between pizza sauce and straight-up tomato sauce?

Tomato sauce is always made from tomatoes, with a few herbs and spices added. While pizza sauce is typically made using tomatoes, some do not include tomato at all, favoring cream or pesto as the base. Also, where tomato sauce is versatile – it works well with poultry, meat, pasta, and veggies as well as with pizza – pizza sauce tastes strange on other dishes.

3) What are the main spices used for making pizza sauce?

Most store bought tomato pizza sauce contains garlic, olive oil – ideally extra-virgin olive oil – along with basil and oregano.


III. Conclusion

We very much hope today’s guide to choosing the best store bought pizza sauce has given you plenty of inspiration, and we also hope it encourages you to try making your own pizza at home.

We have included a variety of styles of sauce so there’s something for everyone, and we highlight any flaws in this sauces as well as flagging where they come good.

Before you leave today, bookmark Madiba. With fall well underway and the holiday season already on the horizon, we have a very busy content calendar for the coming months. Pop back soon for more informative guides and the lowdown on all the best kitchen equipment. We also have much more on offer here at Madiba, so explore our blog and see you soon!

5/5 - (3 votes)

Leave a Comment