The 12 Best Oven Mitts and Pot Holders to Avoid Scorched Fingers

Taking-fresh-baked-shortbread-cookies-from-oven-in-kitchen

How many times have you burned your fingers transferring pots and pans from the oven to the kitchen counter?

How often have you dropped and smashed your pan because you grabbed a wet kitchen towel to act as a makeshift oven mitt?

If you’re anything like most of us, both of these things have probably happened more than once.

There’s no need for that, though. The best oven mitts and pot holders are so inexpensive, and some of them so stylish, that there’s no reason not to add one to your kitchen.

While these mitts are simple in terms of both design and execution, there are still a few pointers worth considering to streamline your buying decision.

  • Materials: Most of the best oven mitts are made from cotton, often a soft terry cloth. This can withstand temperatures of up to around 200F, but only for a few seconds. Cotton is highly breathable, and as such will transfer the heat rapidly. Given that most of your cooking will take place above this temperature, most oven mitts bundle in an extra layer of protection. Rubber oven mitts give you a firmer grip than you’ll get from cotton, and the heat won’t transfer as quickly as through cotton either, since rubber isn’t breathable. Silicone oven mitts can bear temperatures to around 500F or more, and you’ll also be able to hold hot items for 30 seconds or more, perfect to avoid rushing in the kitchen and causing an accident. You can also find neoprene oven mitts and Kevlar oven mitts
  • Protection: You need to ensure any oven mitts on your shortlist can perform the core job of keeping your fingers, hands, and arms protected from burning pots and pans. Pay close attention to the above materials and look out for silicone mitts. You should also spend a little time exploring a few users reviews. Relying on the manufacturer’s claims regarding heat resistance is not always wise. Genuine feedback from consumers often gives you a fuller view. To save you the trouble, we’ve done this for you, and we summarize the performance of all the mitts on our shortlist in this key area
  • Maneuverability: However protective and heat resistant the oven mitts, there are not much use unless you can comfortably and easily maneuver pots and pans while you’re wearing them. When you’re wearing a great example of an oven mitt, it will feel like an extension of your hand. It shouldn’t feel too bulky or restrictive, or it will end up doing more harm than good
  • Washing and care: You need to make certain that any oven mitts on your shortlist are simple enough to clean. Many are machine washable, and some are even safe to dry on a low heat in the machine. Others mitts are safe to pop in the dishwasher. We draw your attention to the few models with issues when it comes to cleaning
  • Storage: Many of the best oven mitts come with hooks so you can hang them up and streamline storage. This is not a deal-breaker, but it makes a nice bonus
  • Multipurpose or single-purpose: With some oven mitts, you get nothing beyond a straight-up glove. Others serve double duty as trivets or pot holders. Choose in line with your needs

OK, given the simple nature of oven mitts, you now have absolutely everything you need to confidently compare all of the best models on the market. We review a dozen of the finest examples so you can pick the right oven mitts for your needs.

Madibarestaurant.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

I. The 12 Best Oven Mitts and Pot Holders

1. Our #1 Pick: HOMWE Professional Oven Mitt

HOMWE-Extra-Long-Professional-Silicone-Oven-Mitt,-Oven-Mitts-with-Quilted-Liner

Features

  • Material: Silicone and polyester cotton
  • Weight: 12oz
  • Dimensions: 11 x 5.5 x 0.7 inches

First up and our favorite overall in today’s showcase of the best oven mitts and pot holders comes from HOMWE, a brand with a solid reputation in this vertical.

Choose from 14 different colors to suit, including this vibrant red pair of mitts.

There are 2 different sizes to choose from, this 14.7-inch model and a smaller 13.7-inch set of mitts.

Made from silicone, these mitts offer protection against temperatures to 450F, and they won’t catch alight if you use them when you’re grilling either.

The waterproof silicone part of the mitts won’t draw in any moisture, and they are breathable, flexible, and comfortable to wear.

Non-slip grips on the mitts ensure you don’t lose your food all over the floor.

Once you’re done, these oven mitts are safe to pop in the washing machine for super-simple care. You’re getting some of the best oven mitts and pot holders here, and you don’t need to dig too deep for the privilege either.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Huge choice of colorways
  • Easy care and machine-washable
  • Non-slip and textured grip
  • Lining is only 10% cotton

2. Gorilla Grip Oven Mitt

Gorilla-Grip-Slip-and-Heat-Resistant-Silicone-Oven-Mitts

Features

  • Material: Silicone and polyester
  • Weight: 13.4oz
  • Dimensions: 12.4 x 7.6 x 1.65 inches

Next up comes the Gorilla Grip oven mitt that’s well worth popping on your shortlist.

The one drawback a few users report with these mitts is the way they are so sticky that they attract lots of dust and lint.

This stickiness comes into its own when you’re handling hot pans and dishes from the oven, though.

The 12.5-inch length ensures all your hands and your arms are protected at temperatures up to 468F.

The silicone shell is extremely easy to keep clean, too. All you need to do is run it under some warm water and you’re good to go.

With no fabric cuff, you won’t need to put up with an unattractively stained pot holder.

The lining of these mitts is nicely padded, giving you a comfortable and ergonomic experience, while protecting your fingers from hot pans.

Each of the mitts comes equipped with a hook so you can hang them up to dry and save on storage space.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Waterproof and heat-resistant
  • Protects you up to 468F
  • Lengthy mitts for extra coverage
  • Sticky and attract lint

3. Big Red House Oven Mitts

BIG-RED-HOUSE-Oven-Mitts,-with-The-Heat-Resistance-of-Silicone-and-Flexibility-of-Cotton

Features

  • Material: Silicone
  • Weight: 10.5oz
  • Dimensions: 13.19 x 6.89 x 2.28 inches

Next up comes a flawed gem from Big Red House in the form of these oven mitts that polarize opinion. Many users are delighted and praise these pot holders, while others call into question the effectiveness of the silicone used.

These mitts are striped with silicone, but this has more of an effect at improving traction when you’re handling pots than protecting you from heat. The claimed heat resistance maxes out at 480F, but we would advise doing your due diligence here.

At 12.5 inches long like most of the best oven mitts, you’ll keep your forearms protected as well as your hands and fingers.

While you should pay attention to those mixed reviews and make your own mind up, you can also take heart in the lifetime guarantee removing any niggles from purchase.

With a cotton exterior and a super-soft terry cloth interior, these mitts are comfortable and supportive, even if they are not the most robust performers in terms of heat protection.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Silicone striping for added grip
  • Protect your wrists and forearms
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Mitts are not highly heat-resistant

4. HOMWE Oven Mitts and Pot Holders

HOMWE-Silicone-Oven-Mitts-and-Pot-Holders,-4-Piece-Set,-Heavy-Duty-Cooking-Gloves

Features

  • Material: Silicone and cotton
  • Weight: 1.06 pounds
  • Dimensions: 13.43 x 7.87 x 2.05 inches

Next up we have some more oven mitts from HOMWE, so how do these shape up?

Well, if you’re shopping for oven mitts and pot holders with durability uppermost in mind, we would advise scoping out some of the more rugged mitts we review. Several disgruntled users flag lifespan issues with these pot holders.

Setting this gripe aside, these mitts perform well across the board.

Choose from 7 vibrant color schemes to suit the design of your kitchen. This model is finished in a snappy turquoise.

Each set bundles a pair of 7-inch oven mitts and a pair of non-slip trivets so you can avoid scorching your work surfaces with red-hot pans.

Made from a silicone that’s fire-retardant and heat-resistant, you can confidently handle searing hot cookware without worrying about burning your fingers or the kitchen table. Instead, slip on these mitts and focus on serving up your freshly cooked food.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Choice of bright colors
  • Pair of non-slip trivets bundled
  • Highly durable
  • Some issues with build quality reported

5. Ritz Royale Collection Pot Holder

Ritz-Royale-Collection-100%-Cotton-Terry-Cloth-Pot-Holder-Set

Features

  • Material: Terry cloth cotton
  • Weight: 3.36oz
  • Dimensions: 8.5 x 8.25 x 0.25 inches

The Ritz Royale Collection offers up these oven mitts made from a soft terry cloth cotton, but do they deliver fully?

In a word, no. Like many oven mitts that sidestep the silicone, you don’t end up with quite such a heat protective mitt here. If you frequently handle extremely hot pans, you would be advised to explore some of the silicone oven mitts we review.

For anyone buying oven mitts mainly based on comfort, there are fewer more comfortable options than these. What the terry cloth loses out on in terms of protective properties, it gains in terms of flexibility and comfort.

There are 8 different colorways to coordinate with your kitchen. The colors are also designed to coordinate with the rest of the Ritz Royale collection, including kitchen towels, dishcloths, and aprons. Get everything you need for your kitchen under one roof.

These mitts couldn’t be easier to care for. Not only are they machine-washable, but you can even dry them in the machine on a low heat.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Soft and luxe feel
  • Machine-washable
  • Multipurpose mitts
  • Not the most heat protection

6. GEEKHOM Grilling Gloves

GEEKHOM-Grilling-Gloves,-Heat-Resistant-Gloves-BBQ-Kitchen-Silicone-Oven-Mitts

Features

  • Material: Silicone
  • Weight: 10.6oz
  • Dimensions: 12.6 x 5.71 x 0.55 inches

GEEKHOM make some great grilling gloves, and these are also superb to handle pots and pans when you’re transferring them to and from the oven.

The silicone doesn’t contain any BPA or toxins, so you’ll have no niggling safety concerns.

These are multipurpose mitts and resistant to temperatures from -104F to 446F.

The long sleeves are designed to protect your forearms as well as your fingers, offering complete protection against blistering hot cookware.

You’ll keep a tight hold on your pots and pans thanks to the sticky and non-slip grip, so there should be no nasty surprises when you’re serving up.

The hooks are ideal for hanging these mitts up so they’re ready to grab any time.

While the majority of user reviews for these mitts are overwhelmingly positive, we found some scattered complaints about the small sizing. If you have especially large hands, you may want to check out some of the roomier mitts on our shortlist.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Eye-catching design
  • BPA-free silicone
  • Long sleeve design
  • Quiet small sizing

7. OXO Good Grips Pot Holder

OXO-Good-Grips-Silicone-Pot-Holder

Features

  • Material: Silicone
  • Weight: 1.6oz
  • Dimensions: 9.75 x 7.5 x 0.25 inches

Next up come some great oven mitts from kitchenware specialist OXO. How do these stand and fall, then?

The first thing that divides opinion is the way these gloves have a patterned business side but a soft cotton front. Several users report this makes them harder to keep clean, and also more prone to picking up staining.

This gripe set aside, what else do you get for your money?

Well, that sticky silicone studded onto the hands of these mitts means you’ll confidently handle even piping hot pans and dishes without losing your grip and without burning your arms or your fingers either.

Inside the gloves, the soft padded liner means you won’t end up with chafed fingers while trying to protect them.

Aside from those reported issues with cleaning and staining, these are some of the most effective oven mitts and pot holders you’ll find, so why not give them a try?

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Patterned with non-slip silicone
  • Bright colorways
  • Softly padded liner
  • Front part of mitts harder to clean

8. The Ove Glove

Ove-Glove-Hot-Surface-Handler-Oven-Mitt-Glove,-Perfect-for-Kitchen/Grilling

Features

  • Material: Silicone and Kevlar
  • Weight: 3.4oz
  • Dimensions: 6 x 0.75 x 11 inches

If you’re looking to introduce an element of fun to the kitchen, this protective glove will also help you keep your fingers and arms safe even when handling super-hot kitchenware and cookware.

You get just a single glove here, so make sure you’re comfortable with that arrangement. If you prefer the security of handling pots and pans with both hands, we have plenty of pairs on our shortlist,

Made from Kevlar and a soft double-knit cotton, you get a glove that’s comfortable to wear and ideal for a broad spread of applications, in and out of the kitchen.

The glove is machine washable so you won’t have any hassles with upkeep.

Designed to be worn on either hand and containing space for all five fingers, you’re in safe hands with The Ove Glove. Even if exposed to a direct flame, the outer of this glove won’t catch fire.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Machine washable
  • Fun styling
  • Multipurpose gloves
  • Some complaints about quality control

9. OXO Good Grips Oven Mitt

OXO-Good-Grips-Silicone-Oven-Mitt

Features

  • Material: Silicone
  • Weight: 5.3oz
  • Dimensions: 13.7 x 7 x 0.5 inches

Next up comes another iteration of the OXO Good Grips oven mitt, so how does this pot holder differentiate itself in a crowded field?

While there isn’t the widest choice of colors, you still have a handful of options at your disposal, and let’s face it, you’re not buying oven mitts primarily for their good looks.

This is a single glove so you should be sure this meshes with your needs. Some people insist on using a pair of mitts, and we review several of these if you prefer that added security. If you’re happy with one glove, read on.

Inside the glove, there’s a soft cotton lining, and the outer of the glove comes studded with a diamond pattern of silicone to improve traction and reduce the chances of you dropping your roast all over the floor.

At 13 inches long, this is one of the roomiest oven mitts on our shortlist, and you’ll keep most of your arms protected, not just your fingers.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Several muted colorways
  • Easy to wipe clean
  • Diamond-patterned and grippy
  • You only get one mitt

10. Lifaith Pot Holder

Lifaith-100%-Cotton-Kitchen-Everyday-Basic-Terry-Pot-Holder-Heat-Resistant-Coaster-Potholder

Features

  • Material: Terry cloth cotton
  • Weight: 0.32oz
  • Dimensions: 7.2 x 1.9 x 7.5 inches

As we near the end of our quest for the best oven mitts and pot holders, here comes a great example from Lifaith.

The first thing that strikes you is the enormous choice of colors. There is no excuse not to match your mitt to your kitchen décor with this many options at your disposal.

This is a great value set containing 5 separate pot holders finished in a soft yet durable cotton. This terry-looped cotton should protect your hands from hot pans while also providing a safe base for hot cookware you don’t want burning a ring in a wooden table.

The lining of these pot holders is a heat-resistant silverstone, further protecting your pinkies from the heat of pots and pans coming out the oven.

Although most user reviews of these pot holders are positive, we found some blowback with users complaining about the small size of these things, as well as the flimsy build.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Huge choice of colors
  • Heat-resistant silverstone lining
  • Soft cotton inner
  • Quite small and thin

11. Ritz Royale Collection Pot Holders and Oven Mitts

Ritz-Royale-Collection-100%-Cotton-Terry-Cloth-Mitz,-Dual-Function-Pot-Holder/Oven-Mitt-Set

Features

  • Material: Terry cloth cotton
  • Weight: 7.2oz
  • Dimensions: 8.5 x 5.5 x 0.75 inches

Next up is another entry from the Ritz Royale Collection, perfect if you like to color-coordinate all your kitchen towels and oven mitts.

Available in a choice of colors to suit, each pack contains 4 pot holders. These versatile terry cloth cotton mitts can be used either as a traditional oven mitt or as a pot holder.

Measuring up at 8.5 inches long and 5.5 inches wide, you’ll get plenty of space however you use these mitts.

Not only do you get versatility in terms of application, but you can also use these mitts with a variety of cooking methods, from the oven and BBQ to the grill and smoker.

Machine washable for your convenience, you’ll find these oven mitts as easy to take care of as they are to use, and you shouldn’t ever burn your fingers in the kitchen again.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Set of 4 mitts
  • Machine washable
  • Dry in the machine
  • Color bleeds so wash separately

12. All-Clad Textiles Oven Mitt

All-Clad-Textiles-Oven-Mitt,-2-Pack,-Pewter

Features

  • Material: Cotton and silicone
  • Weight: 11.7oz
  • Dimensions: 14 x 7 x 0.75 inches

All-Clad makes some impeccable kitchenware, so it’s no surprise that their textiles division churns out the same high-quality gear at a reasonable price.

These mitts are heat-resistant up to an impressive 600F, making them among the strongest performers in the game. Each pack contains a pair of mitts, so you won’t need to fish pots and pans from the oven one-handed.

Made from a long-lasting cotton twill, these gloves are not only highly protective but also extremely comfortable to wear.

The only complaints we could unearth among a welter of positive reviews concerns the thumbs being quite short. If you have larger hands, these mitts might not make the snuggest fit.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Heat-resistant to 600F
  • Rugged cotton twill
  • Silicone treatment
  • Thumb is too short for many users

II. FAQs

To round out, a curated list of the most frequently asked questions about oven mitts and pot holders.

1) What different designs can I find in oven mitts?

Oven mitts and pot holders come in many different designs. Long oven mitts are lengthy and flexible. They are also much more durable than regular cooking gloves. Stretching right up over your forearms, this style of oven mitt offers robust protection without totally compromising comfort. Single oven mitts obviously tend to come out cheaper, but you’ll also lack the protection you want on both hands. For safety and comfort, opt for a set of double oven mitts instead. If you like the idea of retaining maximum maneuverability, you could consider some fingered oven gloves. Most classic oven mitts are in the traditional mitten style. Here, you get a single slot for all your fingers together, and another area for your thumb.

2) How do oven mitts work?

The principle of oven mitts is straightforward. The materials used to make them offer a very low conduction of heat. As such, the heat shouldn’t transfer from the cookware through to your hands. This principle explains why wet oven gloves never work as effectively as dry gloves.

3) Why can’t I just use a kitchen towel?

You certainly could use a kitchen towel or a tea towel, and many people do. Although this may offer some degree of protection against heat, this method has several drawbacks. Firstly, there is more chance the towel will be wet than a traditional oven glove. Water does not stop heat well as outlined above. Also, you’ll need to fold a kitchen towel in order to get the requisite protection. This increases the chance of the dish slipping out of your hand.

4) What’s the difference between oven mitts and pot holders?

The terms are used interchangeably. The main difference you see is that dedicated pot holders often lack the fingers you find on oven mitts. The core purpose of these is to protect your work surfaces from scorching hot pans. Many of the best mitts double up to perform both of these roles.

5) What are the best materials for oven mitts?

When it comes to the inside, most of the best oven mitts are made of a soft and breathable terry cloth cotton. The outside of the best pot holders is usually silicone. This serves to stop heat transferring through to your hand, and it also promotes the great grip you need when you’re handling hot and slippy pots and pans.


III. Conclusion

If you arrived here at Madiba without the first idea about choosing the best oven mitts and pot holders, you should now have a wide selection of options to choose from.

Silicone mitts tend to offer the best protection against heat, and this mitts are also textured to help prevent any slippage when you’re handling hot kitchenware.

Choose the most appropriate design of mitts or pot holders for your needs, whether that’s the classic mitten style or a set of fingered gloves. To a large extent, the dishes you usually cook will dictate the most suitable style of oven mitts.

Before you go today, bookmark our blog. We are expanding right now, so we’ll be bringing you even more great content than ever. Come back soon and don’t miss out!

Leave a Comment