The 16 Best Cigar Humidors

Best-Cigar-Humidors

If you enjoy smoking cigars from time to time, you may want to give some thought to properly storing them for long-term use.

Cigars degrade quite quickly if they are not carefully stored, and it today’s comprehensive guide to the best cigar humidors, we’ll provide you with the perfect tools to achieve this.

Fortunately, humidors are simple devices, but they perform a vital role. The right humidor lets you keep those stogies at relative humidity levels between 64F and 75F, widely recognized as the optimum RH levels for cigar storage.

You might not believe it if you’re new to the world of cigars, but stogies properly stored will taste better with age, just like fine wine.

Now, although buying a cigar humidor is not rocket science, there are nevertheless a few points that will simplify your buying decision.

  • Type of humidor: Cigar humidors come in a variety of shapes and sizes. A desktop humidor, sometimes referred to as a case humidor, is portable and lightweight. These are ideal for home use or for travel purposes.  With metal hinges in place of a vacuum seal, you’ll get reasonable capacity set against a compact footprint. Cigar coolers operate on the same principle as wine coolers. These give you the space for a much larger cigar collection, but they are correspondingly bulkier, so make sure you have the room to accommodate the cooler. For a much smaller alternative, a cigar storage jar lets you keep 10 or so cigars fresh while you’re traveling.
  • Materials: Most freestanding cigar coolers are made from stainless steel, while desktop humidors are made from wood or laminate. Cedar wood is used for its moisture-retaining properties and also for the way it repels insects drawn to your beloved cigars. Drawers should be cedar-lined. Pine makes a reasonable alternative, but cedar is the industry standard
  • Hygrometer: A hygrometer is just like a thermometer, except it helps you measure humidity levels rather than temperature. Some of these units are pretty imprecise, and we draw your attention to this throughout our reviews today
  • Seal: Any humidor lacking an airtight seal and lid means you’re wasting your time and money

Well, aside from keeping your eyes peeled for any worthwhile extras like cigar cutters, if you focus on the above elements, you should have no problem finding the most appropriate humidor for your needs.

Explore our curated list of the best cigar humidors out there, paying particular attention to the seal and hygrometer.

Dive in and enjoy!

Madibarestaurant.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 16 Best Cigar Humidors

Glass-Top-Handcrafted-Cedar-Humidor-with-Front-Digital-Hygrometer

Our favorite cigar humidor overall is this cedar gem from Case Elegance. How does it stand out in a crowded pack?

Firstly, you get a combination of a space-saving form ideal for your desktop with a generous capacity allowing you to store from 25 to 50 cigars. As with all the humidors on our shortlist, capacity is determined by the size of the ring gauge of your preferred sticks.

One of the key selling points is the integrated digital hygrometer. This allows you to effortlessly maintain humidity levels to create the optimum storage environment for your stogies. All you need to do is pick up some solution to keep relative humidity between 65% and 70%.

We found some isolated complaints about the accuracy of the hygrometer, an unfortunately common theme in many hygrometers.

The magnetic seal ensures that the carefully achieved storage environment remains secure at all times.

As you’d expect from one of the best cigar humidors on the market, the cedar lining inside gives you the ideal moisture-retaining environment so your sticks won’t dry out, even if you’re storing them long-term.

There’s an accessory tray baked in. Keep your lighter and cigar cutter close to hand.

Things We Like

  • Digital hygrometer
  • Real Spanish cedar
  • Magnetic seal

Things We Dislike

  • Some issues with hygrometer accuracy

Mantello-Royal-Glass-Top-Cigar-Humidor

Mantello’s cigar humidor is spacious inside with room for up to 50 cigars, depending on the ring gauge. If you smoke larger sticks, you’ll find capacity is reduced to 25. Assuming this gives you ample space for your stogies, how does this humidor shape up?

The rosewood finish adds a touch of elegance to your desk or countertop and gives you a subtle yet striking showcase for your cigar collection.

You can view your cigars through the window on top, meaning you don’t need to breach the storage environment unnecessarily.

Inside, you get a humidifier. Along with the metal hygrometer, you’ll have the means to keep humidity levels in check and at the optimum levels. While most user reviews of this humidor are pretty positive, we found some complaints about the difficulty of adjusting humidity levels.

Not only do you get impressive build quality and performance here, but this is also one of the cheapest cigar humidors out there.

All you’ll need to do to get started is to activate the humidor. Use a 50/50 mix of distilled water and PG (propylene glycol).

Things We Like

  • Space for up to 50 cigars
  • Elegant rosewood finish
  • Rugged build

Things We Dislike

  • Quite awkward to manipulate humidity levels

3. Upgrade Pick: Whynter 250-Cigar Cooler

Whynter-CHC-120S-Stainless-Steel-250-Cigar-Cooler

Whether you have a large cigar collection at home or you need storage for a commercial premises, industry heavyweight Whynter serves up a superb solution with this sprawling humidor.

There are two sizes of this cooler available. This is the smaller with a capacity of 1.2 cubic feet offering enough space to house up to 250 cigars, dependent on ring gauge.

With a thermostat baked in, you can tweak the temperature between 50F and 66F. We’d like to see this go a few degrees higher, but you’ll be able to create a stable and consistent storage environment for your stogies here.

The reliable thermoelectric cooling makes no noise or vibration to disturb you.

Inside the cooler, you’ll get the moisture-retaining cedar used inside all the best cigar humidors. With a humidity tray and hygrometer inside, you’ll be free to keep the humidity levels in check, as well as regulating the temperature. Both elements are key for storing cigars at their best.

There’s nothing much to say against this humidor aside from the fact you’ll need a fair amount of space to accommodate it. In return, you get the means to store large quantities of cigars while keeping them fresher for longer. You can rely on Whynter.

Things We Like

  • Cavernous capacity
  • Broad temperature range
  • Hygrometer and humidity tray

Things We Dislike

  • Bulky and heavy

4. Bald Eagle Handmade Cigar Humidor

Handmade-Cigar-Humidor,-Cedar-Cigar-Desktop-Box-with-Humidifier-and-Hygrometer

Next up we have a bold entry from Bald Eagle with this compact handmade humidor ideal for desktop purposes.

As you’d expect from any smaller cigar humidor, capacity is fairly limited. You’ll have space for anywhere from 20 to 25 sticks, though, so it makes a smooth fit for smaller collections.

Made from Spanish cedar, the humidor is finished with a deep, rich walnut. There are alternative colorways available.

Take full advantage of the onboard hygrometer to regulate humidity levels. We encountered a handful of complaints from disgruntled users calling the accuracy of the hygrometer into question.

If you’re placing this humidor on a desk, you’ll appreciate the scratch-resistant backing.

Aside from the apparent imprecision with humidity levels, this is a worthwhile desktop humidor that’s well worth popping on your shortlist.

Things We Like

  • Sleek desktop solution
  • Dark walnut finish
  • Scratch-resistant underside

Things We Dislike

  • Imprecise hygrometer

5. Scotte Cigar Humidor

Scotte-Cigar-humidor-jar,Leather-Cedar-Wood-Cigar-Canister-Portable-Cigar

If you’re looking for a small travel humidor, or you just need somewhere to keep a handful of cigars at home, Scotte delivers a great solution.

The small leather container looks understated yet luxe. You’ll be amazed how cheap this thing is, too.

The inside of the container is lined with cedar like all the best humidors, so you’ll ensure that the moisture-retaining properties keep your stogies succulent rather than dry and desiccated.

You’ll have room inside for up to 16 cigars. If you smoke thicker sticks, you’ll need to adjust your expectations of capacity.

The hygrometer lets you keep your eye on the humidity levels inside.

Attractively gift packaged, this makes a neat gift for the cigar lover in your life. There’s a handy travel bag thrown in as well so you can take this humidor on the road or out in the RV any time you fancy without misplacing any of your accessories.

Despite the somewhat restricted capacity of this dinky humidor, it makes a wise bet for anyone who enjoys stogies on the go.

Things We Like

  • Perfect travel humidor
  • Leather finish
  • Hygrometer

Things We Dislike

  • Limited capacity

6. Case Elegance Monogrammed Cigar Humidor

Monogrammed-Glass-Top-Handcrafted-Cedar-Humidor

If you’re looking for a thoughtful gift for a cigar lover, the ever-reliable Case Elegance serves up a striking and attractive humidor with a difference. How does this storage unit stand out?

The monogramming option allows you to customize this humidor wonderfully. Whether you’re buying it for yourself or as a gift, make things personal.

Unlike most small desktop humidors, this one boasts a digital hygrometer. This allows you to precisely monitor the humidity levels, ensuring they stay close to the 70F optimum for cigar storage.

Inside the humidor, you benefit from the cedar lining used for its moisture-retaining properties.

Maintaining humidity levels is made super-simple. Included here are some hydro sticks that you coat with a solution of distilled water and propylene glycol to ensure levels stay where they should.

The accessory storage is a great extra and allows you to keep your lighter, cigar cutter, and anything else you need close at hand and ready for action.

This is among the very best cigar humidors out there, looking great and performing strongly across the board.

Things We Like

  • Great gift with monogramming
  • Digital hygrometer
  • Onboard accessory storage

Things We Dislike

  • Some issues maintaining humidity levels

7. Capri Desktop Humidor

Desktop-Humidor,-Capri,-with-Tempered-Glasstop

Desktop humidors provide a compromise between space-saving form and enough room to accommodate anywhere from 25 to 50 of your favorite cigars. The capacity will hinge on the size of the cigar’s ring gauge.

The mahogany finish to this humidor adds a touch of class, while the interior is lined with Spanish cedar. It’s no accident this wood is used for this purpose. It retains moisture wonderfully, meaning your sticks won’t end up dried out, even if you’re storing them for years.

The glass viewing window permits you to monitor your stogies without needing to continually open the humidor. Maintaining a consistent storage environment is key.

If you want to add another touch of customization, there’s a nameplate you can have engraved. This is also a thoughtful extra if you’re giving this humidor as a present.

Although you’ll need to calibrate the analog hygrometer before use, once you’re up and running this is one of the best cigar humidors you’ll find, and it’s very keenly priced, too.

Things We Like

  • Rich mahogany finish
  • Tempered glass top
  • Hygrometer

Things We Dislike

  • You need to calibrate hygrometer

8. XIFEI Acrylic Humidor Jar

XIFEI-Acrylic-Humidor-Jar-with-Humidifier-and-Hygrometer,humidor

What can you do if even a desktop cigar humidor seems a little too big for your needs? Well, XIFEI produces a superb humidor jar offering surprisingly robust functionality for such a dinky unit. What do you get for your money, then?

Firstly, capacity is reasonable for a jar. Depending on the size of the cigars you smoke, you could fit up to 18 of them inside this thing.

The acrylic build is strong enough to give you years of service. The transparent jar has a tight gasket that helps preserve a consistent cooling environment inside.

You’ll get that all-important cedar lining, so those sticks will stay packed with moisture rather than withered and dried up.

You’ll benefit from a hygrometer, as humidity is just as important as temperature when you’re storing cigars. Several users comment about the lack of precision with these levels, though.

Overall, this is one of the best cigar humidor jars in its class, and a great home for a very small cigar collection. This also works very well as a travel humidor.

Things We Like

  • Durable acrylic build
  • Fits up to 18 cigars
  • Cedar wood lining

Things We Dislike

  • Some reported snags with humidity levels

9. Mantello Cigar Humidor

Mantello-Cigar-Humidor

Next in line comes a slightly roomier desktop humidor, again from Mantello.

Depending on the thickness of your cigars – this is expressed in terms of ring gauge – you can expect to accommodate from 50 to 100 sticks inside this thing, ideal for burgeoning collections.

When you’re storing stogies, you need to get both the temperature and the humidity levels right if you want to preserve the best qualities of those cigars. Mantello caters for both this areas in fine style.

A hygrometer baked in makes monitoring RH (relative humidity) levels a cinch. When your cigars are laid out inside the tray, you should find they remain at just the right temperature, too.

The Spanish cedar lining  performs as expected, while the felt-lined base means you won’t end up scratching up your desk while trying to preserve your cigars.

Decorative features extend to the solid brass hinges. This humidor would make a superb gift for anyone partial to a cigar or two. That’s if you can resist the temptation to pocket the humidor for yourself!

Things We Like

  • Holds up to 100 cigars
  • Removable cedar tray
  • Perfect gift for cigar lovers

Things We Dislike

  • Some quality control issues

10. Whynter Elite Touch Control Cigar Humidor

Whynter-CHC-122BD-Elite-Touch-Control-Stainless-Cigar-Cooler

Next up comes another entry from the inimitable Whynter. How does the Elite humidor stand and fall, then?

Boasting 1.2 cubic feet of interior storage space, you’ll have room for over 100 of your favorite cigars inside.

The analog hygrometer is unfussy, but delivers precise humidity monitoring so you can ensure the levels are correct for storing your stogies long-term.

Although user reviews of the Elite are almost universally positive, we found some complaints about the temperature failing to hit 70F, often cited as the optimum temperature for storing cigars. You can keep an eye on the temperature through the LED.

The fan-forced circulation ensures cooling is consistent and even with no warm or cold spots like you find in some cheaper and less effective cigar humidors.

Drawers and shelving are constructed from Spanish cedar. This has the requisite moisture-retaining qualities for cigar storage while the scent repels insects and imparts that trademark smell you associate with cigars.

The cooling system is thermoelectric, so you won’t be menaced by any of the noise or vibration that mars some of the less efficient humidors in this class.

Whether you’re looking to house an ambitious cigar collection at home or you have a small cigar shop and you need a display case, Whynter hit another home run with the iconic Elite cigar humidor.

Things We Like

  • Consistent circulation
  • LED temperature display
  • Removable cedar drawer

Things We Dislike

  • Doesn’t hit 70F

11. Megacra Desktop Cigar Humidor

MEGACRA-Desktop-Cigar-Humidor

Megacra produces some highly effective cigar humidors that look great without costing the earth. This desktop model carries on that tradition admirably.

The cedar box is lined with a supple PU leather giving you the benefits of the real thing without the tedious upkeep. The humidor should give you years of faithful service.

Inside, measurements are 9.25 x 7.9 x 3.2 inches. This translates to space for up to 50 of your preferred sticks, size-dependent.

There’s a rectangular humidifier inside allowing you to create the optimum storage environment to bring out the very best in your cigars.

With a divider cutting across the tray, you can categorize a growing collection so you can access your cigars more easily.

Some users report the fit and finish could do with more attention, but we feel you need to keep your expectations reasonable at this point. You’re not likely to find a piece of custom-made furniture at this price, and we feel overall build is sound.

While this might not be the best cigar humidor, it’s well worth your further investigation if you’re hunting for a desktop model with a generous capacity.

Things We Like

  • Exquisite cedar and leather build
  • Onboard humidification
  • Tight seal

Things We Dislike

  • Finish could be improved

12. Octodor Cigar Humidor by Case Elegance

Octodor-Large-Black-Piano-Finish-Glass-Top-Cedar-Humidor-with-Digital-Hygrometer

Octador’s cigar humidor is pretty pricey, so what do you get if you’re prepared to dig a bit deeper for a humidor?

Firstly, capacity is class-leading for a desktop humidor. You can fit up to 100 cigars inside this thing, ideal for cigar lovers looking to keep a decent collection on hand at home.

As you would expect from industry legend Case Elegance, attention to detail is present throughout. You’ll be able to maintain both temperature and humidity at the perfect levels for short-term or long-term cigar storage.

The magnetic lid offers a tight and secure seal so you don’t need to worry about air penetrating and spoiling your sticks.

The digital hygrometer is pretty precise, an area where much of the cheaper opposition falls down.

Not only does this hygrometer perform well, but it’s also eye-catching and makes a real conversation piece with its octagonal shape and rich, luxurious build. If you have deep pockets and exacting tastes, this is one of the best cigar humidors you’ll find.

Things We Like

  • Generous capacity
  • Magnetic lid
  • Digital hygrometer

Things We Dislike

  • Pretty pricey

13. Prestige Import Group Cigar Humidor

Prestige-Import-Group-Milano-Countertop-Display-Cigar-Humidor

Do you need a storage solution for up to 125 cigars? If so, you’ll obviously need to make sure you have space for a larger unit, and the Prestige Import Group deliver a first-rate humidor here ideal for home or commercial use.

The open display allows your collection to be showcased and viewed from all angles. The cabinet has glass sides all around.

Finished in a deep, dark mahogany, the humidor injects an element of class into your man cave, study, or cigar shop.

A pair of oversized humidifier ensure that the RH levels are optimized for cigar storage. This should be roughly 70%.

Despite offering space for so many cigars, this unit doesn’t eat up too much interior real estate.

If you want to give a growing cigar collection the home it deserves, you can’t go wrong with this impressive freestanding model.

Things We Like

  • Open storage
  • 360-degree viewing
  • Space-saving form

Things We Dislike

  • Internal construction not cedar

14. Woodronic Handmade Cigar Humidor

Woodronic-Handmade-Glass-Top-Cigar-Humidor

As we near the end of our collection of the best cigar humidors, Woodronic serves up a compact and understated model ideal for smaller stashes.

Depending on the size and ring gauge of your preferred sticks, you could fit up to 50 inside the humidor, perfect for a fledgling collection.

The acrylic window lets you peek inside without breaching the storage environment.

Made from real wood veneer, the humidor looks elegant on a desk or countertop, and the underside is lined with a scratch-resistant velvet so you won’t end up scuffing your furniture.

As with all the best cigar humidors, you’ll benefit from a super-tight seal keeping all the oxygen out and your cigars at their finest for longer.

Several disgruntled users have pointed out the hinges on this humidor as the weak point, so we would advise handling with care. This niggles set aside, the Woodronic represents a sleek and understated humidor delivering first-class value for money. What are you waiting for?

Things We Like

  • Holds up to 50 sticks
  • Acrylic viewing window
  • Spanish cedar lining

Things We Dislike

  • Hinges are weak

15. Kendal Cigar Humidor

Kendal-Cigar-Desktop-Humidor

Kendal has a hard-won reputation for producing small but perfectly-formed cigar humidors, and this desktop model continues that winning tradition.

Inside this humidor is space to house up to 50 of your finest cigars. You’ll create a storage environment that ensures they stay fresh without drying out.

In place of Spanish cedar lining the box, you get pine. This wood performs the same task and has similar moisture-retaining qualities, so don’t feel you’re being shortchanged here. Pine, just like cedar, also gives off a wonderful scent.

The tempered glass top keeps harsh light from penetrating and damaging your cigars.

You get an efficient cigar cutter and an eye dropper thrown in, giving you everything you need to get going right off the bat.

The tray inside comes with a divider so you can divide your cigar collection more easily. There is also extra storage space inside, again with a divider.

Mounted front and center, the hygrometer lets you keep track of humidity levels, crucial when you’re storing stogies. We found some scattered complaints about the accuracy of this instrument. This minor niggle aside, the vast majority of user reviews are overwhelmingly positive.

Things We Like

  • 50-cigar capacity
  • Pine lining
  • Humidifier, cutter, and eye dropper

Things We Dislike

  • Imprecise hygrometer

16. Audew Electronic Cigar Cooler

Audew-JC-23C1-Electronic-Cigar-Cooler-Humidor,150-Cigar

Last but not least we have a spacious and user-friendly electronic cigar cooler from Audew that’s well worth a place on your shortlist.

Before anything, make sure you have space for this beast. The cooler measures up at 10 x 17.8 x 20 inches and tips the scales at over 23 pounds. Assuming you have room, you’ll have the capacity to store up to 150 cigars inside.

Double-coated glass doors keep harsh light from spoiling your stogies.

You take control using an intuitive touchscreen panel. This lets you access a temperature range that’s much wider than the competition, spanning 54F to 74F.

Thanks to the thermoelectric cooling, you won’t get too much noise or vibration from this unit.

Internal LED lights ensure you can monitor your cigars without needing to open the door and your sticks will be spared from harsh fluorescent lighting.

If you only smoke the occasional stogie, a cooler of this size is obviously overkill. If, however, you have a robust or growing collection, investing in this oversized humidor might be the smartest decision you make this year.

Things We Like

  • Space for 150 stogies
  • Thermoelectric cooling
  • Broad temperature band

Things We Dislike

  • Temperature issues reported

Conclusion

We very much hope today’s bumper guide to the best cigar humidors out there has given you everything you need to find the most suitable storage solution.

The most crucial elements of your buying decision will concern capacity and overall dimensions. Make sure you factor both of these aspects in to avoid disappointment.

Stick with any of the humidors on our shortlist and you can buy with your eyes wide open. We reveal both the benefits and drawbacks of these humidors so you can find the smoothest fit the easy way. If you encounter a humidor we didn’t review here today, we hope you draw some useful pointers from our brief buying guide.

One request before you go: bookmark ToronadoSD and be sure to pop back soon!

Leave a Comment