The 10 Best Cigar Cutters

Cigar-Cutter

When you first start smoking cigars, you might try lighting them without using a dedicated cigar cutter to slice the ends off.

How did that work out for you?

By investing in the best cigar cutter, you can prepare your stogies perfectly every time without any physical effort.

Unfortunately, it really isn’t easy to find an effective cutter. There are plenty of them out there as you’ll see today with our reviews of the top 10 cutters. The problem is, there are also a great number of poor quality cutters that don’t deliver in terms of performance or lifespan.

Luckily for you, we’re here today to separate the wheat from the chaff and to bring you capsule reviews of a wide range of cigar cutters suitable for thin torpedo cigars through to thick stogies up to 80 ring gauge. We have tried to bring something for everyone today.

We understand, though, that you may have absolutely no idea what to look for when you’re comparing cigar cutters. While they are straightforward in terms of operation, there are several elements worth considering before you whip out your credit card. Focus on the following:

  • Type of cigar cutter: One of the most popular types of cigar cutter is a V-cutter. These are small, lightweight, and portable. They work well at home but also make neat travel cutters. These cutters allow you to slice a wedge shaped like a V in the ends of your cigars. Avoid this type of cutter if you frequently smoke cigars with tapered ends. Setting these cigars aside, V-cutters work well for all other stogies. Aside from this, most cigar cutters feature a double-blade guillotine. With these cutters, you’ll slice the end from your cigars in one clean motion. If you smoke lots of torpedo cigars, this style of cutter is ideal. You’ll also find some scissors-style cigar cutters or even multi-tool cutters. These will never be as effective as a dedicated model but can work well for occasional or travel use
  • Type of cigar: Not all cigars are created equal, specifically when it comes to the shape of the tips. Most commercial cigar cutters will deal with most regular cigars. If you smoke only one type of cigar, it’s worth focusing on a cutter designed exclusively for parejos (cigars with a round head) or for figurados if you smoke other types of cigar. All that counts here is buying in line with your needs
  • Thickness of cigar: Cigars come in many shapes and sizes. The thickness of cigars is expressed in terms of RG (ring gauge). RG runs from 20 to 80. If you’re consistently smoking huge Cohibas, make sure the cutters on your shortlist can accommodate
  • Dimensions: As well as ensuring that the cigar cutter can deal with the ring gauge cigars you smoke, you should also make sure the overall dimensions fit your requirements. If you like smoking cigars when you’re out, look for one of the portable V-cutters on our list today. If you need a desktop model, we have several options below, too
  • Mechanism: A smooth and spring-loaded mechanism will help deliver consistent and accurate cuts, meaning none of the tobacco inside your stogie will unravel

Now, you should have everything you need in place to accurately compare the best models on the market. Make sure you think closely about the cigars you smoke now and how you see your collection develop over time. Get this right and you should find a cigar cutter that lasts for years.

Dive into our reviews and see which of these cutters, if any, makes the right fit.

Madibarestaurant.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 10 Best Cigar Cutters

1. Our #1 Pick: Colibri V-Cut Cigar Cutter

Colibri-V-Cut-Cigar-Cutter,-Black

Our overall favorite in this curated list of the best cigar cutters comes from the industry titan Colibri. How does this cutter shape up, then?

Firstly, you’ll benefit from a strong and durable stainless steel blade that shouldn’t dull after use. Many cigar cutters start strongly but then give up the ghost after a few months of sustained action.

The V-shaped cut delivered will slice large stogies up to 60 ring gauge giving you a great deal of versatility. This cutter also works well with torpedo cigars.

If you smoke exclusively smaller and thinner cigars, this is not the best option for you. We have several cutters on our shortlist ideal for this purpose.

The spring-loaded mechanism makes this cutter easy to use and you won’t need to put in too much effort to prepare your cigars for smoking. You’ll get crisp and even cuts that give you the acute angle you need for a great draw on your cigar as you light it.

Backed by a robust 2-year limited warranty, you can buy with complete confidence and the knowledge the manufacturer has your back.

Things We Like

  • Stainless steel blade
  • Spring-loaded
  • Impeccable brand heritage

Things We Dislike

  • Not ideal for smaller cigars

2. Also Great XIFEI Cigar Cutter

XIFEI-Cigar-Cutter,-Stainless-Steel-V-Cut-Cigar-Cutter

Next up in our quest for the best cigar cutter comes a solid and pocket-friendly example from XIFEI. How does it stand and fall?

The V-cut design of this cutter imparts perfect acutely-angled cuts ideal for most smaller stogies. You can also cut some larger cigars, but that’s not where this cutter comes into its own.

You can easily use this cutter with one hand, and you won’t need to put in too much elbow grease either. It’s spring-loaded so you’ll get smooth and easy cutting.

The inverted stainless steel blade is great right out the box, but several disgruntled consumers report this becoming dull quite quickly.

This cutter comes in an attractive presentation box making it a superb and thoughtful gift for any cigar lover in your life.

If you’re not totally satisfied with this cigar cutter, call in for a no-hassle refund at any stage during the first six months after purchase. What more can you ask for?

Things We Like

  • One-handed operation
  • Spring-loaded
  • No-quibbles refund for 6 months

Things We Dislike

  • Blade slightly dull

3. Budget Pick: Alaska Bear Cigar Cutter

ALASKA-BEAR---Cigar-Cutter-Stainless-Steel-Guillotine-Double-Cut-Blade-in-Black-Gift-Pouch

If you’ve been hunting for a cheap cigar cutter that doesn’t stiff you in terms of performance, you may have found that search frustrating. You can end it right now, though. Alaska Bear delivers a sleek and accurate cutter that’s priced in budget territory, so what do you get for your money?

The stainless steel finish looks much more elegant than many pricier cutters. While you’re not buying one of these devices primarily for its aesthetics, it doesn’t hurt when a cigar cutter looks this good.

The ergonomic cutter sits snugly in your hand and the sharp blades will slice the end from your stogies so they’re ready to light and draw on robustly. The cuts this unit delivers are neat, precise, and consistent. The blades are self-sharpening, a feature lacking on some pricier opposition.

You’ll be well placed when it comes to cigar size. This cutter will cope with sticks up to 60 ring gauge, giving you plenty of latitude.

Most user reviews of this cheap but effective cigar cutter are positive. The few complaints we found concern the sharpness of the blades right out the box.

Things We Like

  • Self-sharpening double blades
  • Clean, precise cuts
  • Ergonomic grip

Things We Dislike

  • Blade could be sharper

4. Cigarloong Cigar Cutter 

CIGARLOONG-Cigar-Cutter-Stainless-Steel-Bronze-Engraved-Double-Cut-Blade

Cigarloong’s cigar cutter is stainless steel finished with either a gold or silver engraving. This is not the subtlest of designs, but the intricate cutter makes a great conversation piece.

Fortunately, it’s not a case of form over function. The double blades are self-sharpening, so they should remain effective long-term.

You can cut cigars from 50 to 55 ring gauge giving you reasonable flexibility. If you consistently smoke thicker sticks, this is not your best option.

Using this cutter is straightforward. Pop your thumb and forefinger inside then pull firmly at a 90-degree angle to cut the end from your stogie.

Customer service is responsive and helpful if you run into any problems, but this simple cigar cutter should give you years of service. If you mainly smoke smaller cigars, this is one of the most efficient cutters you’ll find.

Things We Like

  • Intricate, striking design
  • Self-sharpening double blades
  • Holds 50 to 55 ring gauge cigars

Things We Dislike

  • Not ideal for really thick stogies

5. Xikar Cigar Cutter

Xikar-Xi2-Cigar-Cutter,-Spring-Loaded-Double-Guillotine-Action

Next up is a simple but highly effective cigar cutter from Xikar that gives you everything you need and nothing you don’t.

Suitable for cigars with ring gauges from 54 to 60, this cutter makes a smooth fit if you habitually smoke thicker cigars.

The double guillotine is spring-loaded so you won’t need to put in much physical effort to prepare your cigars for smoking.

While most user testimony is pretty positive, we found some scattered complaints about the blades becoming dull quiet quickly. This is surprising given the 440 stainless steel build, but it’s worth bearing in mind when you’re comparing cigar cutters.

You can choose from a massive variety of colorways to suit, a welcome change in a market saturated with similar products.

As an added kicker, this cigar cutter is backed by a lifetime warranty so you can buy with total confidence and nothing to lose.

Things We Like

  • Cuts 54 to 60 ring gauge sticks
  • 440 stainless steel blades
  • Spring-loaded double guillotine

Things We Dislike

  • Blade dulls quite quickly

6. The Big Easy Tobacco Co. Cigar Cutter

The-Big-Easy-Tobacco-Co.,-Quad-Table-Cigar-Cutter

Next in line we have a solid and substantial desktop cigar cutter from The Big Easy Tobacco Co. that deserves a place on your shortlist.

You get four separate holes in the top of this unit allowing you to cut cigars with ring gauges from 52 to 60, making this one of the most versatile solutions for cigar lovers who enjoy a variety of different sticks.

The two straight guillotine blades deliver straight cuts across the top of your thicker cigars so all you need is the right lighter to enjoy your stogies at their very best.

The stainless steel comes with a brushed finish. This cutter makes a sleek addition to your desk or cigar cabinet and saves you from needing multiple cutters if you have a collection of cigars with various ring gauges.

While the majority of customers appear satisfied with this cigar cutter, a few complained about the price relative to similar competing cutters. Overall, though, there’s little to knock about this model, and it’s also currently available at a discount, so act quickly to snatch yourself a bargain.

Things We Like

  • Slices 52 and 60 ring gauge cigars
  • Two straight guillotine blades
  • Rugged build

Things We Dislike

  • Reasonably pricey

7. Zertone Cigar Cutter

Cigar-Cutter-Guillotine-Stainless-Steel-Double-Blade

Zertone’s cigar cutter is a lean and classic design capable of delivering consistent and accurate V-cuts in most cigars.

The maximum diameter of cigar this cutter can comfortably deal with is 23mm. This translates to a 60 ring gauge, so you can cope with thicker cigars.

The dual guillotine blades are self-sharpening, preserving performance without involving you in any tedious upkeep.

This is a compact and lightweight cutter that works well as a portable travel model.

A few customers report the cuts with this model not being as clean as they would have liked.

Elegantly gift boxed, this cigar cutter makes a superb gift for any cigar lovers in your life. That’s if you can resist the temptation to pocket it for yourself, of course!

Things We Like

  • Stainless steel build
  • Self-sharpening guillotine blades
  • Sleek gift box

Things We Dislike

  • Not the cleanest cuts

8. Vertigo Big Daddy Cigar Cutter

Vertigo-Big-Daddy-80-Ring-Gauge-Cigar-Cutter

Do you consistently smoke really thick cigars? If so, you’ll doubtless have struggled finding cigar cutters to accommodate. Most commercial cutters, even the beefier models, are designed for stogies to 60 ring gauge. Vertigo’s aptly-named Big Daddy, on the other hand, can accommodate sticks to 80 ring gauge.

Despite the generous capacity, this is a subtle and understated cigar cutters that’s all about business.

The blade is made from stainless steel, but it’s slightly disappointing to also see plastic onboard. That said, we couldn’t unearth any complaints from users about lifespan.

The majority of feedback concerning this oversized cigar cutter is positive and you can buy with a clean conscience without needing to spend a fortune. You might not believe just how little this cigar cutter costs considering the performance you get in return.

Things We Like

  • Stainless steel blade
  • Understated finish
  • Fits large cigars to 80 ring gauge

Things We Dislike

  • Plastic parts

9. Tonino Lamborghini Cigar Cutter

Tonino-Lamborghini-Les-Mans-Carbon-Fiber-Cigar-Cutter

As you would expect from anything bearing the Lamborghini brand, this cigar cutter is amazing to look at while outperforming most of the competition.

The cutter is made from carbon fiber, introducing a touch of luxe to your cigar room. You can choose from a variety of colored accents to complement the elegant carbon build. The contrast is eye-catching without looking over the top.

Ideal for all cigars to 54 ring gauge, this is ideal for most smaller and medium-sized sticks. If your frequently smoke larger cigars, there are plenty of bulkier offerings on our shortlist.

The blade is made from surgical-grade stainless steel, so you’ll get unerringly precise cuts and a blade that’s equipped to stay sharper for longer.

You get a leather gift pouch finished in trademark red and black. The cutter also comes warrantied for 2 years giving you total confidence.

 Attention to detail extends throughout this outstanding cigar cutter. It might not be cheap, but just like Lamborghini cars, it’s worth it if you can afford it

Things We Like

  • Carbon fiber build
  • Elegant aesthetics
  • Precise clean cuts

Things We Dislike

  • Quite costly

10. Camlinbo Cigar Cutter

Camlinbo-Cigar-Cutter-with-2-Cigar-Punches

Last but not least in our cigar cutter reviews is a chunky yet lightweight offering from Camlinbo. How does this cutter stand out in a crowded field?

The key selling point here are the two punches. This gives you plenty of flexibility whether you’re dealing with small or large stogies.

The heavy-grade stainless steel blade will neatly slice the top off your sticks so they’re perfectly prepared for lighting. Cuts are accurate and also extremely consistent. The few complaints we could find concerning this model mention the cutting action being slightly rough.

This cutter is compact and portable, and it comes in a velvet bag so you can easily take it with you if you smoke cigars when you’re out and about.

Easy to hold and equally easy to use, this is one of the best cigar cutters in its class and it’s built to stay the distance, too.

Things We Like

  • Dual punches
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Crisp and accurate cuts

Things We Dislike

  • Not the smoothest cuts

Conclusion

If you arrived here today at MadibaRestaurant without the first idea of how to choose the best cigar cutters, that should have changed by now.

While this might not be the most complicated buying decision you’ll face and won’t require the same thought as picking up a humidor or a cigar cooler, it’s still worth taking the time to consider the pointers we outline up above.

If you stick with any of the cigar cutters we review today, you can buy with your eyes wide open and a clear idea of the benefits and drawbacks of these cutters. If you encounter some cutters not on our shortlist, we hope you find out brief buying guide helps inform your decision.

Take a moment to bookmark our blog before you head off. We bring you fresh content daily on all aspects of building out your home bar and cigar room. Come back soon so you don’t miss out!

Leave a Comment