The 10 Best Butter Dishes

Dish-with-butter-and-shovel-on-wooden-table

When you are kitting out your kitchen, it’s easy to overlook basics and essentials like butter dishes.

Butter dishes first appeared in Connecticut in the late nineteenth century. Early iterations of this kitchen classic were made of silver. These dishes included integrated ice chambers to keep the butter chilled.

The French version of the butter dish is known as a pottery crock. These contraptions invert the butter stick so that the exposed portion rests in water to keep it from spoiling.

Why should you consider using a butter dish in the first place, then?

Well, by storing your butter in a standalone container or tray, you’ll help keep the temperature in check, enabling you to easily spread your butter without shredding your bread or dropping the whole pat of butter.

As well as keeping your butter creamier and ensuring it is spreadable, butter dishes also protect your butter from the air, light, and bacteria that can cause it to spoil when not refrigerated.

According to USDA guidelines, it is safe to keep butter at room temperature, but inadvisable to leave it outside the refrigerator for more than a day or two to prevent rancidity. The good news? You can easily pop your butter dish into the fridge.

So, what should you look out for on the buying trail?

  • Type of butter dish: The first issue that will inform your buying decision is what type of dish makes the right fit for you. Do you want a French-style crock where you’ll need to add water to keep butter fresher? Or, are you hunting for a more user-friendly dish where all you’ll need to do is pop your sticks of butter inside? We review some of the best butter dishes in each category so you can see which makes the smoothest fit.
  • Materials: Butter dishes come in many different materials. The most common are ceramic, glass, and plastic. Each of these material offers unique benefits and drawbacks. Ceramic dishes look sleek and contain no toxins or contaminants, but they are quite costly and reasonably heavy. A glass dish is fragile, but its appearance is unbeatable. While this material is food-safe, it is not usually dishwasher-safe and not always microwave safe. Plastic butter dishes are cheap and durable but plastic storage containers divide opinion. All that counts is buying in line with your needs.
  • Cleaning: Depending on the materials used, you may need to wash your butter dish by hand. There are also plenty of dishwasher safe dishes out there.
  • Size: Butter comes in different sizes throughout the United States, and you’ll find European butter sizes also vary. East coast butter is sometimes referred to as Elgin sticks. These 4-ounce sticks are skinny. West coast butter, on the other hand, consists of smaller and stubbier sticks still containing the same 4 ounces of butter. European butter is typically packaged in much wider and flatter blocks, usually weighing 8 ounces rather than 4 ounces. Make sure any butter dish on your shortlist is spacious enough to accommodate the butter you use at home.

Keep these simple pointers in mind and you should easily find the best butter dish for your needs after exploring our reviews.

Madibarestaurant.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 10 Best Butter Dishes

1. Our #1 Pick: Ceramic Butter Dish with Lid

Kook-Ceramic-Butter-Dish-with-Lid,-Kitchen-Countertop-Butter-Keeper

Features

  • Material: Ceramic
  • Weight: 2.18 pounds
  • Dimensions: 7.5 x 3.75 x 3.5 inches

First up and our pick of today’s butter dishes comes from Kook, so how does it shape up?

The primary draw here is the ceramic build. Firstly, ceramic remove the harmful effects of low-grade storage material like plastic. Additionally, this material has natural cooling properties, so you’ll keep your butter at its best for longer.

The benefits of the ceramic build don’t end there, though. You’ll also find this dish is super-simple to clean – it’s even dishwasher friendly. You can even pop the butter dish in the microwave if you need to melt the butter slightly.

Capacity is generous, and you’ll have space inside this dish for a standard 4-ounce stick of butter.

The lid is easy to remove and shaped, so it rests neatly on its side as you slather butter all over your breakfast toast.

We found several complaints from users about this dish leaving scrapes and scratches on the kitchen counter, so we recommend taking care with placement. Setting this gripe aside, you’re getting one of the best butter dishes out there.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Hardwearing ceramic build
  • Microwave-safe
  • Handle streamlines lifting lid
  • Prone to scratching counter tops

2. OXO Good Grips Butter Dish

OXO-Good-Grips-Butter-Dish

Features

  • Material: Plastic
  • Weight: 0.3 pounds
  • Dimensions: 7.9 x 2.6 x 2 inches

OXO is one of the most reliable brands in the kitchenware space. Not only does this company produce intelligently-designed and well-constructed gear, but it’s always keenly priced, too.

To lead off with the drawback, the plastic build polarizes opinion. Per the manufacturer’s website, this plastic does not contain BPA, a known contaminant. That said, not everyone is convinced by plastic storage, so if you prefer a glass or ceramic butter dish, explore some of the options above and below.

If you don’t object to plastic, you’ll appreciate the unbreakable nature of this container.

Inside, you get measurements markings for both eastern-style and western-style sticks.

Ergonomic handles make it easy to shift the dish around on the table or countertop.

Safe for use in the dishwasher although not recommended for microwaving, OXO delivers another home run with this cost-effective and efficient butter dish. As an added kicker, this company donates 1% of its profits to environmental causes, so you can do your part for the planet while enjoying fresh butter on demand.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Stoppers keep butter in place
  • Easy to carry
  • Dishwasher friendly
  • Slightly too small

3. Bezrat Butter Dish

Bezrat-Glass-Butter-Dish-with-Lid-|-Classic-2-Piece-Design-Butter-Keeper-

Features

  • Material: Glass
  • Weight: 0.5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 7 x 4 x 3 inches

What if you don’t like the idea of either a ceramic or a plastic butter dish? Well, Bezrat offers a glass alternative that’s well worth popping on your shortlist.

The key selling point here is the striking design. Several users point out, though, that the dish does not come with BUTTER emblazoned across it as pictured in the product listing. You get a scalloped design that’s easy on the eye, though.

It is also worth pointing out that while this dish is advertised as crystal, it is actually constructed from glass. As such, you’ll need to handle this thing with care.

The transparent nature of this dish lets you easily see how much butter remains.

You should have no problems storing most regular sticks of butter inside this dish, including both eastern and western-style sticks.

Unlike some cheaper plastic dishes, the Bezrat is made from food-safe materials that won’t impart a chemical taste to your butter.

Although you’ll need to wash this dish by hand, it is remarkably easy to keep clean, completing a winning and eye-catching package.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Elegant design
  • Accommodates most regular butter
  • Food-safe and contaminant-free
  • Not etched as described

4. Priority Chef Butter Dish

PriorityChef-Ceramic-Butter-Dish-with-Lid-for-Countertop

Features

  • Material: Ceramic
  • Weight: 1.94 pounds
  • Dimensions: 9.1 x 5.75 x 5.4 inches

Next in line is a superb ceramic butter dish giving you an elegant and traditional storage method for your favorite butter.

Large enough to house a standard butter stick with room to spare, you’ll keep dust and debris from marring your block of butter, and you can also keep it fresh for a day or two outside the refrigerator.

You can choose from a pale or dark blue dish in addition to this classic white option.

This is a pretty heavy and bulky butter dish, but in return you’ll get a solid build that should give you years of faithful service.

Unlike much ceramic kitchenware, this dish is perfectly safe to pop in the dishwasher, saving you from scrubbing away rancid butter by hand.

The handle is designed to help you easily remove the lid. This lid fits very tightly in place, too, so you’ll get no unwanted heat and air penetrating your butter stick.

With the exception of a handful of complaints about the narrow width of this dish, almost all user testimony sings the praises of this offering from the Priority Chef Store.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Keeps butter fresher for longer
  • Snugly fitting lid
  • Easy-lift handle
  • Restrictively narrow

5. Godinger Dublin Mini Butter Dish

Godinger-Dublin-Mini-Butter-Parfait-Dish-Set-of-2

Features

  • Material: Crystal
  • Weight: 1.55 pounds
  • Dimensions: 7.2 x 4.1 x 3.5 inches

Next for something slightly different with this pair of mini butter dishes from Godinger Dublin.

The first thing to clear up concerns construction. Despite playing on its Irish heritage, the company produces these crystal dishes in China. The molten crystal is not of the highest standard, and it is unclear whether it contains any contaminants. The product listing further muddies the water by referencing silver and pewter. So, if you’re looking for some lead-free crystal storage, you’re in luck.

The attractive design of these dishes makes them ideal for dinner parties and special occasions, but they are hardwearing enough for everyday use, too.

You should be aware that these dishes are quite small, so you won’t be able to slip a whole stick of butter inside.

Overall, we feel these butter dishes look great but it’s unfortunately a case of style over substance.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Pair of lead-free crystal dishes
  • Perfect for dinner parties
  • Unbeatable brand heritage
  • Not the best quality crystal

6. Rubbermaid Standard Butter Dish

Rubbermaid-naaa-Standard-Butter-Dish-7.8

Features

  • Material: Plastic
  • Weight: 0.35 pounds
  • Dimensions: 9 x 6 x 3 inches

For anyone who doesn’t object to using plastic containers for food storage, Rubbermaid serves up a basic butter dish that’s worth a second look.

The plastic dish certainly won’t win any design awards, and it’s not the type of thing you’d want on the table at a dinner party. For day-to-day use, though, plastic butter containers can be highly effective.

The thick build means this container is practically unbreakable, and care is straightforward, as with all plastic butter dishes.

You can easily accommodate a full 4-ounce stick of butter, both thin and thick variants.

As with all the most effective butter dishes you can snap the lid tightly closed to prevent oxygen and heat from spoiling your butter.

While this might not be the most impressive butter dish from a visual standpoint, you can’t knock its functionality.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Thick plastic build
  • Snap-fit lid
  • Holds quarter pound of butter
  • Appearance is a let-down

7. The Original Butter Bell

Butter-Bell-The-Original-Butter-Bell-Crock-by-L.-Tremain

Features

  • Material: Ceramic
  • Weight: 0.29 pounds
  • Dimensions: 3.9 x 3.9 x 4.1 inches

Maybe you’ve explored the butter dishes above, but you like the idea instead of a traditional French-style butter crock. If so, The Original Butter Bell is arguably your strongest option.

You’ll first need to choose from the 11 different colorways on offer. This iteration has a classic stone finish. All dishes have a glazed matte finish, so they look fantastic, and they don’t let you down when it comes to performance either.

We know you’re not buying a butter dish primarily for its good looks, though. With this model, you’ll need to add water to the base of the crock. All you need is one-third of a cup to keep a single 4-ounce stick of butter fresher for much longer.

Once you have your softened butter and water inside the crock, close the lid and create an airtight seal so your butter doesn’t spoil.

For anyone feeling more adventurous, try introducing herbs and flavored oils to generate butter with a twist.

If you simply want a no-nonsense butter dish, you may find this model too complicated. Once you master the simple set-up, though, you’ll appreciate how fresh this dish keeps your better.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Wide choice of colors
  • Striking glazed finish
  • Extremely durable
  • Some issues with consistency

8. EasyDancing Butter Dish

Porcelain-Butter-Dish-with-Bamboo-Lid

Features

  • Material: Porcelain
  • Weight: 2.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 6 x 3 x 3 inches

This top-notch porcelain butter dish is oversized and capable of accommodating all sticks of butter with room to spare.

The bamboo lid not only makes a wonderful visual contrast with the porcelain dish, but it also comes with an inbuilt butter knife. This rests in a slot on the lid so you have everything you need within reach.

The construction is free of all contaminants and toxins, so you can enjoy your toast at breakfast time with no niggling health concerns.

Among a shower of benefits, the only real drawback here is the weight and bulk of this dish. Setting this aside, you’re getting a versatile storage container that’s great for butter and much more.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Multipurpose storage
  • Lid with integrated butter knife
  • Free of lead and other toxins
  • Heavy and bulky

9. Progressive ProKeeper Butter Dish

Progressive-ProKeeper-Butter-Container

Features

  • Material: Plastic and silicone
  • Weight: 0.25 pounds
  • Dimensions: 2.9 x 6.5 x 3 inches

This plastic butter dish from Progressive comes with an inbuilt bonus in the form of the silicone seal. Keep your butter in an airtight environment, then, without needing to spend a fortune.

You’ll appreciate the measurement markings inside this dish, ideal for all sticks of butter. Thanks to the transparent cover, you can see how much butter remains at a glance without needing to remove the lid.

Sitting on a sturdy and stable silicone base, you won’t have any nasty accidents when you’re buttering toast in the mornings.

Although the construction is BPA-free, we encountered a few complaints from consumers reporting this dish imparting a taint to their butter. This is a risk you run with all plastic storage containers, so buyer beware.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Airtight silicone seal
  • Measurement markings inside
  • Non-slip base
  • Imparts chemical taste to butter

10. Royalty Art Butter Dish

Royalty-Art-Glass-Butter-Dish-with-Handled-Lid

Features

  • Material: Glass
  • Weight: 1.6 pounds
  • Dimensions: 8 x 3.8 x 4 inches

To round out our showcase of the best butter dishes, we have an arresting glass model from Royalty Art. How does it stand and fall, then?

Made from borosilicate glass, you’ll find this container is more robust than one made from traditional glass. Resistant to staining and discoloration, you should wash these dishes by hand for best results.

The long and rectangular dish is ideally shaped to house most standard sticks of better, whether the thick or thin variety.

We discovered mostly positive user feedback apart from some reported issues with the poor quality of the finish.

Overall, we feel this butter dish manages to combine ease of use, versatility, and performance while also looking great on the dining table.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Made from borosilicate glass
  • Lengthy and rectangular
  • For all types of butter and more
  • Poor finish

Conclusion

If you were stuck for ideas when looking for a butter dish for your home kitchen, today’s guide should have changed that for you.

Most butter dishes are designed to accommodate both thick and thin 4-ounce sticks of butter, so the most important element of your buying decision concerns the materials the dish is made from. With ceramic, glass, and plastic at your fingertips, take you time and determine which of these materials best meets your needs.

We have a busy content calendar for the coming months here at Madiba, so make sure you bookmark our blog before you leave today and be sure to pop back soon. We update our content daily, so don’t miss out!

5/5 - (1 vote)

Leave a Comment