The 12 Best 4 Slice Toasters

Retro-green-4-slice-toaster-with-four-slices-of-toasted-bread-popped-up-and-one-slice-on-a-white-plate-with-a-cup-of-coffee
If you’re shopping for toasters that can accommodate bigger hunks of artisan bread or bagels, you should opt for either a long-slot toaster or a 4-slice toaster.

Many long-slot toasters only offer you the ability to cook 2 slices simultaneously, though. These appliances are ideal for compact kitchens, but they might leave you wanting if you have a large family you need to cook breakfast for.

With the best 4-slice toasters, you get all the benefits associated with long-slot models, and you also get a guaranteed 4-slice capacity.

Aside from the additional slots for longer pieces of bread or 4 slices of regular prepackaged bread, shopping for one of these toasters is much like shopping for a regular toaster. If you’re new to this, focus on the following pointers:

  • Aesthetics: With an appliance that gets as much use as a toaster, you need something you think enhances your kitchen counter. After all, the toaster is typically one of the focal points of the kitchen. Many of the models we review today come in an array of muted colorways, so you have options beyond black or silver. Once you’ve got the design in place, what else should you consider?
  • Build quality: Assuming the toasters on your shortlist look the part, they also need to be fittingly constructed. Stainless steel is the optimum material for toasters
  • Dimensions: While having a large-capacity toaster is undeniably handy, it also demands more room on the kitchen counter than a regular toaster. We break down the dimensions of all the toasters we review so you can make sure you have the space to accommodate
  • Slot size: Establish that you really need 4 slices in the first place. If not, stick with a smaller model for better results. If you fail to fully load any toaster, you risk inconsistent results. If you have the room to accommodate and you’re happy with a bulkier toaster, think about the type of bread you toast. If you’re a fan of thicker loaves, ensure the slots on any toasters you’re considering are wide and long enough
  • Shade settings: Everyone has their own preference when it comes to toast coloring. Look for a toaster featuring multiple shade settings and make sure these are easy to use
  • Extra settings: Defrost is a valuable feature. This enables you to toast bread from frozen. If you want to reheat food without further browning, the reheat feature on many toasters lets you do this. For bagel lovers, toasters with dedicated settings will help you crisp up the outside of your bagel without overcooking it or spoiling that trademark taste and texture

OK, with those simple elements in mind, you should now be in the position to compare some of the best 4-slice toasters out there. Throughout our reviews, we draw your attention to how well these toasters fare with a variety of different breads, from artisan loaves and croissants to bagels and muffins. See if any of these beefier toasters deserves a place in your kitchen this summer.

Madibarestaurant.com is reader-supported. When you buy via the links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no cost to you.

The 12 Best 4 Slice Toasters

1. Our #1 Pick: Cuisinart Classic 4-Slice Toaster

Cuisinart-CPT-180P1-Metal-Classic-4-Slice-toaster

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Weight: 6.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11.15 x 10.65 x 7.5 inches

Cuisinart has a heavy presence in the kitchenware vertical, and with toasters like this 4-slice model, it’s easy to see why.

The brushed stainless steel chassis not only looks great on the kitchen counter, but it’s also built to withstand sustained use.

You can customize your toast with the 6 available shade settings. Give everyone their toast just the way they want it with the minimum of fuss.

The toasting slots are extra-wide, so you should find no issues if you toast thicker slices of artisan bread.

If you love bagels for breakfast, you’ll appreciate the dedicated setting. This returns great results every time rather than scorching one side of your breakfast bagel. The Cuisinart will heat one side of your bagel only so it stays soft and chewy underneath.

This toaster is super-simple to use, and you can see what you need at a glance with the LED indicators.

Backed by a comprehensive 3-year guarantee, you can buy with the complete confidence that you’re getting one of the best 4-slice toasters out there.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Great choice of browning settings
  • Impeccable brand heritage
  • BPA-free build
  • Customer service issues reported

2. Cuisinart 4-Slice Plastic Toaster

Cuisinart-CPT-142P1-4-Slice-Compact-Plastic-Toaster

Features

  • Material: Plastic
  • Weight: 4.5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 10.8 x 10.7 x 7.2 inches

Next up we have another entry from Cuisinart, this time at a keener price.

In exchange for snatching yourself a bargain, you’ll have to put off with a plastic rather than stainless steel build. Available in black or white, the toaster won’t win any design prizes, but it doesn’t look ugly either.

What you lose in terms of design and build you gain when it comes to control. With a class-leading 7 shade settings, everyone in the family can have their breakfast made to order at the twist of a dial.

Each side of this toaster comes with independent controls. There are simple ergonomic buttons for the bagel setting, as well as defrost, reheat, and cancel.

While the bulk of user reviews for this toaster are positive, we found some gripes about the flimsy build and a few complaints about the consistency of toasting results. If you’re looking for a cheap 4-slice toaster that won’t let you down, this model is well worth popping on your shortlist.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Wide variety of shade settings
  • Multiple toasting functions
  • Dedicated bagel setting
  • Doesn’t toast both sides of bread

3. KRUPS 4-Slot Toaster

KRUPS-KH734D-Breakfast-Set-4-Slot-Toaster

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Weight: 5.28 pounds
  • Dimensions: 13.5 x 13.34 x 8.58 inches

KRUPS are famous the world over for their coffee machines, but they also make a great range of kitchen appliances like this 4-slice toaster.

As you would expect from this brand, you get an appliance you’ll be delighted to leave out on the countertop with its brushed stainless steel finish.

Luckily, it’s not a case of form over function, though. Dual control panels allow you to take charge of each side of this toaster independently.

You can access the 4 functions with push-button ease. The defrost feature is perfect for toasting bread right out the freezer, while reheat and cancel cover the other main bases. The special bagel setting lets you toast these breakfast treats to perfection without overdoing them. You’ll get your bagels lightly warmed on the outside and toasted on the inside.

A high-lift lever saves you from fiddling around when your toast is done.

Although we found predominantly positive user reviews for this model, there were also a number of complaints about the slow toasting speed.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Accommodate all types of bread
  • Super-simple to use
  • 6 different shade settings
  • Not the quickest toaster

4. Breville 4-Slice Smart Toaster

Breville-BTA840XL-Die-Cast-4-Slice-Smart-Toaster

Features

  • Material: Metal
  • Weight: 9.48 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11.9 x 10.9 x 7.7 inches

You know where you stand with Breville gear and this 4-slice smart toaster is one of the finest appliances in their wide line.

The metal chassis is finished in a striking stainless steel, giving you a utilitarian toaster that looks great in modern kitchens.

If you love toasting artisanal and specialty breads, you’ll appreciate the extra width of the slots. This toaster is also ideal if you toast lots of bagels. Defrost frozen bagels and then toast them without burning them in the Breville.

Variable browning control allows you to tweak the shade settings to suit.

Push-button functionality ensures you’ll be up and running right out the box. You can keep your eye on toasting by monitoring the LED indicators.

Once you’re done with breakfast, cleaning the toaster couldn’t be easier thanks to the removable crumb tray.

Aside from a few reported niggles with the lowering and lifting mechanism, this is one of the strongest performers in the 4-slice toaster class.

Backed by a 1-year limited warranty, you’ll have at least some peace of mind at the point of purchase, even if the guarantee could be lengthier.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Great for toasting bagels
  • Feature-rich model
  • LED progress indicator
  • Some issues with lifting mechanism

5. Sencor Metallic 4-Slot Toaster

Sencor-STS6072BL-Premium-Metallic-4-slot-High-Lift-Toaster

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Weight: 5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11 x 12 x 8 inches

Next in line in our quest for the best 4-slice toasters comes a basic but effective model from Sencor.

The metallic finish comes in a number of colorways to coordinate with your kitchen. Although it’s made from stainless steel, this unit feels slightly flimsy.

The electronic timer offers you 9 shade settings, making this the class-leader when it comes to choice of browning levels.

Thanks to the toaster rack thrown in, you can warm your croissants or buns safely and easily inside this toaster.

The stay-cool housing means there’s no chance of scorched fingers when you’re making breakfast.

The power cord wraps away to streamline cord clutter on the kitchen counter. The removable crumb tray takes the sting out of clean-up and completes a winning package, even if this toaster doesn’t come from the most well-known brand out there.

This toaster couldn’t be easier to use and offers a great variety when it comes to the color of your toast, as well as the color of your toaster.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Minimalist aesthetics
  • Easy to use
  • Straightforward to clean
  • Limited functionality

6. BUYDEEM 4-Slice Toaster

BUYDEEM-DT-6B83-4-Slice-Toaster,-Extra-Wide-Slots

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Weight: 6.1 pounds
  • Dimensions: 12.2 x 6.97 x 11.02 inches

BUYDEEM is another lesser-known brand with a toaster well worth your further investigation.

The pastel finish and stainless steel build makes this toaster a smooth fit in both modernist and more traditional kitchens.

A dedicated bagel and muffin setting lets you cook these tasty treats so they come out like the results from a coffee shop rather than scorched abominations that end up in the bin. When you’re making bagels in the BUYDEEM, the toaster first toasts both sides briefly. After this initial burst of heat, only the cutting side of your bagel is toasted for exceptional results every time.

The wide slots come with self-centering properties so you’ll have no hassles when you’re loading in your favorite bread. The width of these slots means thicker specialty bread will slide in without sticking to the sides.

Take care when you’re toasting as this model has a reputation for causing the toast to burn, even when you’re running it at one of the lower shade settings – you have 7 in total to choose from here.

Despite giving you space to slice 4 pieces of toast at the same time, this compact toaster won’t eat up too much kitchen real estate.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • 5 core functions
  • Wide range of shade settings
  • Compact and space-saving form
  • Can burn toast even at low settings

7. Yabano 4-Slice Toaster

Yabano-4-Slice-Toaster,-Bagel-Toaster-with-7-Bread-Shade-Settings-and-Warming-Rack

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Weight: 5.13 pounds
  • Dimensions: 13 x 12 x 7 inches

Next in line comes another 4-slice toaster from a brand that might not be the first that springs to mind when you’re looking for kitchenware. If you’re prepared to take a chance on an unknown, what do you get for your money?

The commanding aesthetics and low-slung design means this toaster is a smart addition to any kitchen counter. Although you get space for 4 slices inside, this is a squat and space-saving unit ideal for smaller or cramped kitchens.

You get a robust range of settings including defrost, reheat, and cancel.

The bagel setting ensures you get your bagels at their best rather than burned or stuck onto the sides.

The addition of a stainless steel warming rack gives you even greater scope when you’re making breakfast and allows you to create delicious toasties as well as straight-up toast any shade you want it.

With 7 different browning levels to choose from, the whole family can eat toast just the way they like it. All you need to do to make this happen is twist a simple dial: what’s not to love?

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Understated design
  • Stainless steel warming rack
  • Fast results
  • Flimsy and lightweight

8. Cuisinart Leverless 4-Slice Toaster

Cuisinart-Touch-to-Toast-Leverless-toaster,-4-Slice,-Brushed-Stainless-Steel

Features

  • Material: Brushed stainless steel
  • Weight: 6.5 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11.42 x 10.08 x 7.75 inches

Cuisinart has yet another great model up for grabs here with this leverless 4-slice toaster. As with all toasters in this class, you can rack up multiple slices of bread at the same time, ideal for busy mornings when everyone’s starving.

The simple design married to rugged stainless steel build means you’ll have an attractive addition to the kitchen counter and a versatile appliance letting you cook a variety of toasted breads to perfection.

While this is not a dedicated wide-slot or long-slot toaster, you’ll still have more than enough room for thicker slices of bread, as well as your favorite breakfast bagels. Use the special bagel setting so you get these treats done to a turn instead of mashed to the side of your toaster or burnt to a crisp.

Backed with a lengthy 3-year limited warranty, you can expect plenty of lifespan from this 4-slot toaster, and it’s not too expensive either, so what are you waiting for?

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • LCD to monitor proceedings
  • Slick design
  • Cord wraps away after use
  • Inconsistent countdown

9. KitchenAid Pro Line Toaster

KitchenAid-KMT4203SR-Pro-Line-Series-Sugar-Pearl-Silver-4-Slice-Automatic-Toaster

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Weight: 19 pounds
  • Dimensions: 113.7 x 12.7 x 9 inches

KitchenAid has a deep bench of toasters with this model hailing from the Pro Line. How does it stand and fall, then?

Firstly, the long-lasting stainless steel build finished in a muted sugar pearl makes a commanding statement on the kitchen counter. We appreciate the fact you’re not buying a toaster mainly for its good looks, though.

Take control of each side of this toaster independently, so whip up toast for both kids at the same time, even if they like their bread toasted at different brownness levels. Choose from 6 different shade settings from pale to super-dark.

A bagel setting ensure there’s no guesswork or inconsistent cooking results when it’s time for smoked salmon and cream cheese with your favorite sourdough bagel.

The spacious slots are ideal if you frequently toast thicker slices of artisanal bread, too.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Auto lift and lowering
  • Frozen and bagel features
  • Great for artisan bread
  • Heavy and bulky

10. LOFTER 4-Slice Toaster

4-Slice-Toaster,-Long-Slot-Toasters-Best-Rated-Prime

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Weight: 4.98 pounds
  • Dimensions: 17.72 x 7.68 x 8.27 inches

As we near the end of our collection of the best 4-slice toasters, we have a great example from LOFTER, another brand that might not trip off the tongue but is well worth a place on your shortlist.

Low-slung and constructed from hardwearing stainless steel throughout, this toaster should give you plenty of faithful service.

One thing to watch out for here is the way the exterior of the toaster tends to heat up dramatically. Keep your fingers well clear of the chassis to avoid any scorched fingers and cursing.

The backlit blue LCD lets you watch the countdown timer, great if you’re always dashing around in the morning cooking breakfast for the whole family.

Reheat and defrost modes give you maximum versatility in a single and reasonably compact unit.

The bagel setting is well-reviewed with many consumers complimenting the way this toaster turns out your favorite breakfast treats.

The slots are wide enough to readily accommodate all your favorite specialty breads, and you can tweak the shade of your toast through 7 different settings to suit.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Digital countdown display
  • Highly effective bagel setting
  • 7 browning settings
  • Outside of toaster gets very hot

11. Cuisinart 4-Slice Toaster

Cuisinart-CPT-T40-Touchscreen,-4-Slice-Toaster,-Black

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel
  • Weight: 6.8 pounds
  • Dimensions: 11 x 10.35 x 7.2 inches

Yet another model from Cuisinart as we edge to the end of our 4-slice toaster reviews.

The first thing that strikes you with this toaster is the ease of use. The slick digital touchscreen is a pleasure to navigate, even if you’re not the biggest tech lover.

Each side of the 4-slice toaster can be controlled separately. One portion gives you a choice of 6 shade settings, while the other segment allow you to flick between the 5 modes:

  • Bagel
  • Defrost
  • Cancel
  • + 30 seconds
  • Single slice

The single slice mode is ideal if you live alone. Often, inconsistent results in a toaster come about if you don’t load all the available slots. So, if you want the flexibility a 4-slice toaster affords, but the ability to enjoy a single round of toast uncompromised, this is the ideal solution.

As with most of the best 4-slice toasters, the substantial slots allow you to easily accommodate bulkier slices of artisanal bread. Give this powerful toaster a try and let us know how you get on.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Easily navigable touchscreen
  • Excellent bagel setting
  • Extra-wide slots
  • This model has been discontinued

12. All-Clad Stainless Steel Toaster

All-Clad-TJ824D51-Stainless-Steel-Digital-Toaster-with-Extra-Wide-Slot,-4-Slice

Features

  • Material: Stainless steel and plastic
  • Weight: 8.23 pounds
  • Dimensions: 13.31 x 12.91 x 8.98 inches

Last but by no means least in our roundup of the best 4-slice toasters comes a model from the highly reputable All-Clad.

Now, while this brand is known for its rugged build quality and precision engineering, we found a number of complaints from consumers alleging that this toaster fails to meet the company’s usual mark of excellence. You should do your own due diligence here, but it’s worth flagging these unfavorable reviews.

If you feel the 4-slice model is a little too bulky for your needs, this toaster is also available in a smaller 2-slice variant.

Self-centering slots ensure even thick and uneven slices of bread or bagels sit where they should for perfect toasting every time.

If your toast pops up and you think it needs a tiny extra burst of heat, push More Time and it should be finished to perfection.

Overall, this is one of the best 4-slice toasters you’ll find, offering you great flexibility from a brand you can rely on.

Things We Like Things We Dislike
  • Wide slots are self-centering
  • Slick release mechanism
  • Reheat and defrost
  • Lots of plastic

II. FAQs

1) What kind of bread can I toast in a toaster?

The type of toaster you buy will impact the versatility you enjoy when it comes to experimenting with different breads. With many standard toasters, especially if the slots are narrow, you’ll struggle toasting anything more than medium or thick pre-sliced bread. When you step up to 4-slice toasters and long-slot toasters, you’ll benefit from much more room inside. This allows you to confidently, consistently, and evenly toast artisanal bread, specialty bread, bagels, and muffins.

2) How long does it take to toast a slice of bread?

The first variable is the type of bread you use. Dry prepackaged bread will take much less time to toast than fresh bread. Beyond this, you also need to consider how you like your toast done, whether that’s pale, dark, or somewhere in between.

3) Do 4-slice toasters accommodate both thick and thin breads?

Yes. The majority of toasters in this class come with self-centering mechanisms that ensure your toast is ideally positioned inside, whatever the thickness.

4) What can I do if pieces of bread get stuck inside my toaster?

Avoid poking inside with metal objects. Unplug the toaster before you do anything else at all, and then wait for it to cool completely. Either upend the toaster over the bin so the hunk of bread falls out, or reach down inside if the bread is within easy grasp.

5) How can I properly clean my toaster?

Just like when you’re removing debris as above, you need to first unplug your toaster and allow it to cool down. Remove the crumb tray and dispose of all the breadcrumbs. Wash the tray with some warm soapy water and let it air dry thoroughly. Use a damp microfiber cloth to wipe down the chassis of the toaster. Replace your crumb tray and you’re ready for the next round of toast.

6) What is the purpose of self-adjusting guides on a toaster?

This simple centers slices of bread to guarantee even results every time.

7) Why do I need a warming rack on a toaster?

A warming rack certainly isn’t essential if you just want basic toast, but for anyone looking to widen their options, a rack allow you to experiment with naan breads, croissants, tortillas, and super-chunky homemade artisan breads.

8) What relevance is the wattage of a toaster?

The higher the wattage of your toaster, the quicker it will toast bread. Toasters with low wattages tend to produce toast that’s too chewy and not crispy enough on the outside. When you’re looking at 4-slice toaster, you should prioritize models rated at 1800 watts or above. With smaller 2-slice toasters, 1000 watts is sufficient.


III. Conclusion

We hope today’s roundup of the best 4-slice toasters has shown you that you have plenty of options if your breakfast menu includes bagels, artisan breads, or croissants.

Most of the models we review come with a dedicated bagel setting, so look out for these if you’re partial to some breakfast bagels.

Take a moment to bookmark Madiba before you head off. We have a very busy month ahead and we’ll be bringing you informative guides daily, so come back soon and don’t miss out!

Leave a Comment